16 Handles is a dessert shop offering a rotating menu of Artisan frozen yogurt, ice cream, vegan soft serve, and other treats plus an endless toppings bar.
Love having frozen yogurt but 16 handles is just an average chain compared to others. Today it was the first time going and finding out that there is a limit on how many samples you can try per person which is two fyi. Only was told that after I asked for a sample cup if they had one and wasn’t informed by the only worker there until I was about to grab a cup to fill that there is a limit. They should inform the customer first instead of saying nothing until later and didn’t see any signs indicating that. Also, it was dead empty in there at the time. Well at least she was nice about it I guess and greeted me when I came in. Three stars this time but will give it another try again soon! ☺️🤞
Edit- after looking up if there is actually a limit to how many flavors you can try before committing there isn’t. I now feel like I was looked at by the employee as someone who was just trying to get free samples and leave but that was not at all true. I did leave with purchasing one to take out and mind you I was really the only consumer there. Only one other customer came in very briefly during my visit. I had every intention of getting a cup to purchase the better way of going about it is saying “are you finding everything ok?” Instead of saying (direct quote) “just so you know for next time only two samples per customer.” Sorry going to have to knock down my review to one star after looking up that. Attached is a screenshot of what I found out by looking up if there is an actual limit for 16 handles try samples before committing. If I ever go back I’ll go there with someone and not by myself again lol!😌
KS
Kashvi Sikka
Apr 7, 2026
1.0
The staff is so so so extremely rude. They told me I couldn’t take a second spoon when I was sharing the froyo with my freind. What kinda rule is that? And even if it policy, it can expresses in a decent manner. I mean, c‘mom man what happened to decent human interaction. Do better seriously!
CH
Chloe H
Feb 22, 2026
4.0
Expensive but delicious. 4 vegan options for froyo then lots of toppings to choose from 🥰
JM
Julie Moses
Dec 16, 2025
5.0
The 5 star review is entirely based on their star employee Domini. Everytime she’s working the store is spotless and well organized - great customer service as well!
TJ
Tanya Jain
May 5, 2022
5.0
Lazaro is genuinely such a nice staff member, he made my friends and I feel so welcome and he even took a picture of us to put on the wall!! I will definitely be coming back, best frozen yogurt place!!
16 Handles offers a rotating menu of Artisan frozen yogurt, ice cream, vegan soft serve, and other treats plus an endless toppings bar.
Where is 16 Handles located?
16 Handles is located at 428 3rd Avenue, New York, NY 10016, USA in the Murray Hill neighborhood.
What are the opening hours for 16 Handles?
16 Handles is open Monday to Wednesday and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 10:00 PM, and Thursday to Saturday from 12:00 PM to 11:00 PM.
What payment methods are accepted at 16 Handles?
16 Handles accepts American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
How can I place an order online for 16 Handles?
You can place an order online through their ordering website at https://orders.16handles.com/order-type.
How can I contact 16 Handles by phone or email?
You can call 16 Handles at +1 212-213-1755 or email them at murrayhill@16handles.com.
Is there a mobile app for 16 Handles rewards or promotions?
Yes, you can download the 16 Handles app to earn free frozen yogurt. More information is available at http://16handles.com/faq.
What nearby restaurants can I visit before or after enjoying treats at 16 Handles?
Nearby restaurants include Accent (Mediterranean), La Cocina (Mexican), Kurry Pavilion (Indo-Chinese), Bareburger (American burgers), and Barlovento Latin Bistro (Latin American/Spanish).
Are there coffee shops close to 16 Handles for a full dessert and coffee experience?
Yes, nearby coffee shops include CRÈME, Moka & Co, Birch Coffee, and Oren's Daily Roast, perfect for complementing your dessert visit.
If I visit 16 Handles in Murray Hill, what beauty and salon services are nearby?
Nearby beauty and salon locations include Nyc Looking Good (beauty salon and lounge), Salon Lexington (hair and beauty salon), Color Nails Bar (nail salon), and Hair Bar NYC (hair salon and barber).
Brand Certified Facts from 16 Handles
This information is certified by 16 Handles and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified May 17, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: