Seafood RestaurantCatererWedding VenueLive Music VenueTake Out Restaurant
Located at the Westlake Marina, right next to the docks, Westlake Fish House has that old Montauk vibe combined with new and innovative ways to serve seafood. Sit inside or outside at the Dockside Bar and watch boats come in with their catch. Our menu features local seafood, fresh sushi, fish & chips, chowder, raw bar, even a kid’s menu. Families welcomed. Live music everyday in season. No Reservations.
Westlake Fish House
352 Westlake Drive, Montauk NY 11954
Westlakefishhouse.com
631 668 FISH (3474)
Unfriendly staff and terrible service. We waited an hour just to be seated, and then another hour for the food to arrive. After all that waiting, the food was average at best—certainly nothing special enough to justify the long wait or the poor service.
The horrible experience started with an unhappy hostess who had a terrible attitude and continued with a waiter who was completely disorganized.
Don’t go unless you’re prepared to wait for hours and be treated poorly. An awful experience from A to Z.
MG
Marie Grupp
Aug 10, 2026
1.0
We were told there would be a 1 hour and 15 min wait which we excepted it turned out to be longer and by the time we were seated it was 9pm. Our waiter was extremely rude we were told oh its late the kitchen will not be happy why were we even seated if there was an issue. The place opens at 5 and closes at 10 . After our food was served and we finished eating they started to stack up chairs at the table next to us not professional at all. The waiter made several rude comments and never said thank you. I should not have left a tip which I did 20 percent my mistake. If a manager or owner reads this they should speak to their employees about good customer service it was not there. We have eaten here in the past and it was run with alot more professionalism.
DC
Dan Campbell
Aug 7, 2026
5.0
Great Mtk classic
Sushi is amazing and best french fries in town!
ET
Edward Tomaiuoli
Aug 5, 2026
5.0
Great food and service. Beautiful views of the harbor
JG
Jaqueline Gavagan
Jul 16, 2026
2.0
We specifically requested no red onions in the chicken gyro and asked for the tzatziki sauce on the side. While the sauce was served on the side, the gyro still arrived with red onions mixed throughout salad. When we brought it to our waitress’s attention, her response was simply, “Well, the sauce was on the side,” as if that made the mistake acceptable.
The service throughout our visit was unprofessional and dismissive. Two people in our group also had serious shellfish allergies (crab and shrimp), and when we mentioned our concerns, the waitress replied, “Well, this is a seafood place.” That was an inappropriate and concerning response to a legitimate allergy issue.
Overall, the poor service, lack of attention to dietary requests, and dismissive attitude made for a very disappointing dining experience. We may not return.
Frequently Asked Questions About Westlake Fish House
Where is Westlake Fish House located?
Westlake Fish House is located at 352 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, USA, right at the Westlake Marina next to the docks.
What type of cuisine does Westlake Fish House offer?
Westlake Fish House serves local seafood, fresh sushi, fish & chips, chowder, and has a kid's menu, combining traditional Montauk seafood vibes with innovative dishes.
Does Westlake Fish House have indoor and outdoor seating options?
Yes, customers can sit inside or outside at the Dockside Bar, enjoying views of the boats coming in with their catch.
Is Westlake Fish House family-friendly?
Yes, Westlake Fish House welcomes families and provides a children's menu and high chairs.
Does Westlake Fish House offer live music?
Yes, there is live music every day in season at Westlake Fish House, creating a vibrant atmosphere.
What are the payment options accepted at Westlake Fish House?
Westlake Fish House accepts American Express, Cash, MasterCard, and Visa as payment methods.
Does Westlake Fish House serve alcohol and cocktails?
Westlake Fish House serves wine and cocktails but does not serve other types of alcohol.
Is Westlake Fish House open every day?
No, the restaurant is currently closed every day of the week according to the provided hours information.
What nearby fishing charters can customers explore before or after dining at Westlake Fish House?
Customers can visit fishing charters like Lady Grace Montauk Fishing Charters, Fishooker Charter Service, Mishell II Fishing Charters, or Bloodline Sportfishing located near Westlake Fish House for fishing experiences.
What local attractions are close to Westlake Fish House for visitors to enjoy?
Visitors can check out Westlake Marina for boat watching, Susie E II Sportfishing monument, or relax at nearby accommodations like Snug Harbor Motel & Marina and Montauk Harborside Resort Motel.
How can the nearby Westlake Marina help visitors find Westlake Fish House?
Westlake Fish House is located right at the Westlake Marina docks, making the marina an easy landmark for visitors to locate the restaurant and enjoy waterfront dining.
Brand Certified Facts from Westlake Fish House
This information is certified by Westlake Fish House and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified August 16, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: