Luigi's Pizza

Reviews

• AL

  Amin Love

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Lorrrie was amazing ! My first time here and she recommended two great slices
• SC

  salvatore cannarozzo

  May 8, 2026
  5.0
  Great food excellent service the atmosphere and music is very relaxing the Italian guy that served me was so nice Thank you best pizza in Lindenhurst try it you won’t be disappointed
• LT

  Lorie Turner

  Apr 27, 2026
  5.0
  Found Luigi’s just after they opened. Now this is NY and pizza joints are everywhere, one is walking distance from my house BUT Luigi’s is the best!! My daughter and I use to go once a week to have lunch. Lately we’ve ordered online pick up/delivery. Not that we don’t like to go anymore, the staff is wonderful and the new look is comfy cozy. Highly recommend if you need a place or a change or just add to your choices, try Luigi’s!! You won’t regret it Pinky promise🤭 (Pictured is their 14’ pie)
• BM

  Brandon Mcnerlin

  Apr 17, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered eggplant parmesan alla vodka sauce and they delivered eggplant Parmesan with regular sauce but they had the audacity to charge me extra for the sauce witch they never gave me. I called up and the guy was ok at first but then started to argue about the sauce how he sees the pan it was made in. I don't care about that you never argue with a customer you tell the customer you're sorry and can I do to make it right. I'll never order from them again this is now the second time they did this I figured they would have changed it's been 3 months since I ordered or more nope
• ET

  Eric Thomas

  Apr 10, 2026
  5.0
  Following a long day house hunting, I stopped by Luigi's Pizza on Montauk Highway in Lindenhurst. We enjoyed the Sicilian and barbecue slices, and they were delicious. I recommend Luigi's if you are in Lindenhurst