Cafe DeWitt opened in 1973 as a small coffee shop for the residents of the then newly repurposed Ithaca High School building. The Cafe is the legacy of William Downing who had the vision to turn an old school building into a lively community of restaurants, stores, offices and apartments. Over the years the Cafe has expanded to offer an extensive breakfast and lunch menu featuring many locally and regionally sourced ingredients that are lovingly prepared by Chef-Owners Denise O'Leary and Benjamin Roach. We are well known for our 3-time Best of Ithaca awarded weekend brunch that is bolstered my many rotating specials. Our staff is the heart of the business, they are constantly striving to deliver a welcoming dining experience that reflects the desire that we share to cook and serve with love.
Explore offerings from Cafe Dewitt on 215 N Cayuga St in Ithaca, with popular hot beverages, cold beverages, breakfast, and entrees available at this location.
Beverage Menu
9 items
Hot Beverages
gimme! dark blend coffee
refills free with food purchase
gimme! colombia la primavera decaf
refills free with food purchase
choice organic teas
earl grey, english breakfast, decaf english breakfast, green, chai spice, rooibos, peppermint, chamomile
served all day - all of our eggs are local, free-range, organic eggs from Autumn's Harvest Farm
Brioche French Toast
$12.00
made with vanilla rum batter , with house mixed berry jam and NYS maple syrup
Farmhouse
$10.80
two eggs, roasted potatoes, toast and house jam; with cheese or egg whites (+1); with local bacon, chicken apple sausage or local smoked ham (+2)
Chef’s Plate
$12.00
roasted potatoes sautéed with red onion on fresh spinach with cheddar and two eggs; with toast
Fried Egg Sandwich
$6.00
on sourdough toast with mayo
Fried Egg Sandwich Deluxe
$9.60
on sourdough toast, local smoked ham, cheddar and mayo
Morning Glory Sandwich
$9.60
scrambled egg, cheddar, tomato chutney, local bacon, and mayo on toasted multigrain
John "Denver" Sandwich
$10.80
omelette with local smoked ham, sautéed green peppers and red onion, local cheddar and sriracha aioli on toasted multigrain.
Laurel Breakfast Sandwich
$10.80
Chicken apple sausage, romesco, wilted spinach, scrambled local egg, red onion, melted cheddar and mayo on sourdough
Breakfast Burrito
$10.80
fried local egg, refried black beans, roasted potatoes, sautéed red onion, local cheddar, crema, flour tortilla. Choice of salsa verde or roasted tomato salsa.
Tiberius Breakfast Sandwich
$10.80
Local pork breakfast sausage, scrambled local egg, gouda, tomatoes, caramelized onions and mayo on a sesame roll.
Omelette
$12.00
up to three fillings, with toasted baguette; egg whites (+1) Choose from: gruyere, cheddar, asiago, brie, local feta, local chevre, manchego, local bacon, local smoked ham, roasted potatoes, spinach, roasted red peppers, red onion, tomato, avocado, crimini mushrooms, tomato chutney
Local Smoked Bacon Or Smoked Ham
$6.00
from Autumn's Harvest Farm
Chicken Apple Sausage
$4.80
from Les Trois Petits Cochons
Rosemary Garlic Roasted Potatoes
$4.80
the best breakfast potatoes!
Toast Sourdough, Multigrain Or Marble Rye
$3.60
from Ithaca Bakery
Lunch Menu
25 items
Entrees
Maryland Crab Cakes
$16.80
house made with lump crab meat; with cucumber, avocado, mixed greens and remoulade
Spice Rubbed Salmon
$15.60
with pickled beets, red onion, capers, mixed greens and remoulade
Macaroni and Cheeese
$9.60
House made creamy three cheese macaroni and cheese; with a side salad
Salads
Dewitt
$13.20
local smoked ham, house roasted turkey, hard boiled egg, carrot, tomato, cucumber, gruyere and croutons with roasted garlic thyme vinaigrette
Dewitt
$10.80
without meat
Cobb
$14.40
local organic chicken breast, local smoked bacon, avocado, hard boiled egg, cherry tomatoes, blue cheese and croutons with a red wine vinaigrette
Terra
$13.20
avocado, hard boiled egg, pickled beet, red onion, capers, carrots and croutons with creamy balsamic dressing
Zoë
$13.20
apple, maple spiced pecans, dried currants and danish bleu cheese on baby spinach with fig rosemary balsamic vinaigrette
House
$10.80
manchego, apple, carrot, pumpkin seeds and croutons with sherry dijon vinaigrette
Small Side
$6.00
tomato, cucumber, carrot and croutons with roasted garlic thyme vinaigrette
Sandwiches
Café Turkey
$13.20
house roasted turkey breast, local bacon, tomato, avocado, red onion, mayo and red leaf lettuce on sourdough toast
Blackforest
$13.20
local smoked ham, cucumber, dill, gruyere, dijon, mayo and red leaf lettuce on sourdough toast
Italian
$14.40
local smoked ham, genoa salami, pepper-olive relish, sharp provolone, sundried tomato vinaigrette, shredded lettuce, tomato, red onion and mayo on toasted ciabatta
Michel
$13.20
local bacon, brie, herbed aioli, cranberry chutney and baby spinach on toasted ciabatta
Sofia
$13.20
white bean and garlic hummus, local feta, spinach, carrot-apricot chutney, red onion, cucumber and toasted almonds on a whole wheat wrap
Classic BLT
$12.00
local smoked bacon, tomato, lettuce and mayo on sourdough toast
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$13.20
Made fresh to order with local organic chicken breast, celery, red onion, fresh herbs and mayo; served on toasted sourdough with romaine, tomato and mayo
Buffalo Chicken Salad Wrap
$13.20
Made fresh to order with local organic chicken breast, celery, blue cheese and buffalo sauce; served in a whole wheat wrap with romaine and tomato
Lamb Merguez Sandwich
$13.20
Lamb Merguez sausage, fried local egg, sauteed red onion and tomato, shredded lettuce, local feta and herbed aioli on toasted pumpernickel.
Grilled Sandwiches
Charlotte
$13.20
house roasted turkey breast, avocado, gouda, baby spinach, red onion and herbed aioli on multigrain
Rubenesque
$13.20
smoked local ham, local caraway sauerkraut, gruyere and russian dressing on rye
Bella
$13.20
Balsamic roasted portobello mushrooms, roasted tomatoes, baby spinach, red onion, sharp provolone, basil hazelnut pesto and sundried tomato vinaigrette; grilled on focaccia
Burgers
made with local grassfed beef
Classic Cheeseburger
$14.40
Made with local grassfed beef; with local cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo on a sesame bun. Add a side salad for $1
Mushroom Swiss Cheeseburger
$14.40
Made with local grassfed beef; with gruyere cheese, sauteed mushrooms, caramelized onion, dijon mustard and mayo on a sesame bun. Add a side salad for $1.
Bacon Deluxe Cheeseburger
$14.40
Made with local grassfed beef; with gouda, local smoked bacon, house made pickles, sauteed red onion, yellow mustard and mayo on a sesame bun. Add a side salad for $1.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cafe Dewitt
Does Cafe Dewitt accept reservations?
No, Cafe Dewitt does not accept reservations.
What pickup and delivery services does Cafe Dewitt offer?
Cafe Dewitt offers in-store pickup, curbside pickup, and delivery services.
What are the operating hours for Cafe Dewitt?
Cafe Dewitt is open Thursday through Saturday from 8:30 AM to 2:30 PM and Sunday from 9:00 AM to 2:00 PM. It is closed Monday through Wednesday.
What type of cuisine and food does Cafe Dewitt specialize in?
Cafe Dewitt specializes in breakfast, brunch, sandwiches, and coffee, focusing on locally and regionally sourced ingredients.
Where is Cafe Dewitt located?
Cafe Dewitt is located at 215 N Cayuga St, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA.
What payment options are accepted at Cafe Dewitt?
Cafe Dewitt accepts American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Check, Discover, Mastercard, PayPal, and Visa.
Can I view Cafe Dewitt's menu online?
Yes, you can view the menu on their website at https://www.cafedewitt.com/.
What nearby coffee shops or bakeries can I visit before or after dining at Cafe Dewitt?
You can visit nearby Little Ram Bakery for fresh baked goods before or after your meal at Cafe Dewitt.
Are there any nearby shops or galleries I can explore near Cafe Dewitt?
Yes, nearby you can explore Sola Art Gallery for arts and entertainment or The Bookery bookstore for a great selection of books.
What amenities are available nearby Cafe Dewitt for a relaxing day out?
Nearby, you can find The Dewitt Mall for shopping, 2Eleven Beauty Bar and Luna Love Holistic Hair Studio for beauty treatments, and Crane Hill Professional Massage for massage therapy.
Brand Certified Facts from Cafe Dewitt
This information is certified by Cafe Dewitt and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified August 09, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: