Came all the way from Rancho Cucamonga, So. California to have another taste of the best pizza east of the Mississippi! Once again had fantastic pizza for Parents Day Weekend at West Point. Far better than the name sake pizza we also had before…bravo!!
GA
Giovanni Alfonso
Sep 25, 2026
When I tell you, I just had the best slice of my life… I had to go back in and get another one to bring to my wife just to prove to her I had the best pizza ever! I was looking for a quick bite and stopped in to grab a slice… The sexy slice is by far the best slice!! Don’t walk here… Run!!! I can’t wait to try the rest of the menu. I don’t really leave reviews like that, but when I tell you that slice of pizza was amazing… Try for yourself 🥁🏆
DH
Derek Hughes
Sep 21, 2026
I don’t leave reviews but I left the restaurant very confused. The employees would only allow me to place my order on the touch screen until I told them I’m paying in cash. I ordered a pizza to go and a pint of Warsteiner Oktoberfest beer while I waited. The employee asked me if I knew how to pour the beer and gave me a pint of mostly foam. Then when I went to pay he told me the pint was $10.95. That’s a $6-7 pint anywhere else. Wish I knew the price before he poorly poured it. Less than 10 min later he walks out from the back with my pizza which was very confusing. How quick it was, which is nice but a fresh pizza takes longer than that to make and bake. And the pizza ovens are in the front of the store. The pizza does look and smell good but overall I’m just confused and ripped off.
SV
Sudhakar Viswanathan
Sep 19, 2026
Great place to stop by after visiting Bear Mountain! We asked for vegetarian options, and the owner was very friendly and went out of the way to customize the pizzas for us, including different varieties half-and-half. The service was exceptional, the food tasted great, and we really enjoyed the ambiance. Overall, a wonderful experience and definitely worth visiting!
WB
William Brodhead
Sep 19, 2026
Another heater find by myself and C. First off, the range of food served was perfect. A range that befits the culture of the establishment— espresso, gelato, pizza, pasta. Real authentic Italian. 3 minute drive from bear mountain, perfect place to fuel before/after a hike. Beers on tap, coffee delicious (great coffee), pizza was awesome (even had pasta on a pizza, fresh calzones, all perfect consistency and taste), didn’t try the gelato but it looked delicious too. Proper chefs who clearly pride themselves on their craft.
Enough about the food, though. Ambience was great. Cozy, nothing overbearing, felt like it grew out of the ground. Tomato cans stacked in the back. Warm, inviting cabin interior. We will be back.