Joey's Pizza Depew

Reviews

• DC

  desiree chamberlin

  Jun 20, 2026
  5.0
  I grew up in Buffalo but moved to Florida in 97. We make a mission to get the pizza, wings and subs EVERY time we come to town perfect crust, and sauce every time. The people and service is always top notch as it has been since the beginning. No one compares and my boyfriend from Florida agrees, perfect wings and of course the BEST Royal subs ever!!!! We love our Joeys! Last time (2025) we hit up Joeys on Broadway just as good!!! Vinny with me in 2012 ❤️he always remembered me
• CE

  Cheryl Esquilin

  Jun 19, 2026
  5.0
  I have been going to the George Urban location for as long as I have lived near them. Since 1996. They are awesome! Pizza is my favorite and of course wings and Steak hoagy is my favorite! Everything is delicious. Kudos to Joeys!!!!🍕🍗🥙
• RS

  Renee Stahlecker

  Jun 19, 2026
  5.0
  I have been a customer since the original owners, and when AJ took over he did not disappoint and has been true to keep it as it once was! Joeys is and always be my go to spot! When I’m craving a sweeter sauce, it hits the spot hands down. The royal sub and chicken finger sub are amazing! It’s a must have when family from Florida comes to visit
• SN

  Scott Nowak

  Jun 17, 2026
  1.0
  This was the worst experience I’ve ever had. Thought the food tasted a little funny. Large chz and pep light sauce. Well woke up a few hours later and had to run to the toilet and then my four year old son also had to do the same. We both got food poisoning from this place. Horrible quality! U don’t want to go through what my son and I did last night. They need to do better!
• CS

  Clark Squires

  Jun 7, 2026
  5.0
  Joey's Pizza on George Urban Blvd. is a favorite whenever family comes to visit! A smaller parking lot that always has a free spot makes pick-up easy. Inside is small with that older, pizza shop aesthetic. There's a couple chairs and tables, but honestly, it's not really a dine-in spot. The crew working the ovens and counter are friendly. As of 2026, I've been coming to Joey's Pizza for a few years so they recognize me a bit, but they've always been courteous and accommodating. Buffalo-style pizza done well, with a doughy undercarriage and sweet red sauce, albeit Joey's Pizza isn't too sweet when compared to other pizza places I've had around Buffalo, in my opinion anyway. A sheet cheese and pepperoni pizza is the family go-to with plenty of sauce and mozzarella cheese and a healthy amount of pepperoni - Enough to fill a family of four and have leftovers. Their small size pizzas, 12"/8 slices, are nicely sized for one (that's what I get 99% of the time haha). Their specialty pizzas are great, with my favorites being Vincenzo Pizza, a stuffed hot pepper pizza with steak, Steak & 3-Cheese Pizza, and their Meat Lovers Pizza! If you like your pizza a little more firm underneath or want it cut differently, Joey's Pizza does a good job accommodating that. Pizza pricing is pretty reasonable, especially with how prices everywhere have gone up in 2026. If you're looking for a solid Buffalo-style pizza for a reasonable price, I definitely recommend Joey's Pizza!