Fire on the Lake

Reviews

• KA

  Kristy Aldrich

  3 days ago
  5.0
  I’ve ordered from Fire on the Lake 3-4 times (some eat-in, some carry out) and the pizzas are always excellent! Tonight I ordered online after kayaking further down the lake. The pizza was ready and waiting when we got there, 5 min faster than expected! Staff was friendly and welcoming. We decided to purchase a couple drinks and eat outside on the patio. They had so many great options for beer, wine, soda, and more. It was the perfect way to end a day on the lake! Great casual atmosphere, lake view from the patio and great people watching. Fire on the Lake is a welcome addition to Lakeshore Drive in any season! We will be back again and again!
• KB

  Kyle F. Brown

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Picked up 3 pies take out. The order was ready right on time and they were all delicious. We'll definitely be back!
• DT

  Donna T

  Aug 11, 2026
  5.0
  This was my first pickup order. I am so impressed that you got it right because I cannot have cheese on my Pizza! You just don't know how many times other shops have gotten that wrong. Thank you!!!
• LC

  Lisa Carro

  Jul 31, 2026
  5.0
  This was our second time eating at Fire on the Lake. The pizzas here are great! Even though it was very busy, the person working the register did a great job taking care of everyone.
• GG

  Gavin

  Jul 24, 2026
  4.0
  The pizza frankly was not that good, but the Otisco Panuozzi was probably one of the best food I’ve ever had. Genuinely stellar. It’s a shame though that the pizza isn’t that good. My main issue was the pizza felt way too small for the cost and it was really dry. I got the Canandaigua pizza and it really could have used more sauce and maybe some olive oil.