Fire on the Lake

Reviews

• LB

  Lori B

  3 days ago
  1.0
  First impression of the front end girl is that she’s “out there” our wing choices were honey bbq or medium well… what? It was said more than once until I asked medium buffalo?? The worst pizza I’ve ever had! The edges were charred on both pizzas, no flavor and almost frozen like pizza shells. Over priced for unenjoyable food.
• RR

  Robert Reynolds

  May 7, 2026
  5.0
  The pizzas were delicious! The sauce, cheese, crust ratio was spot on.
• KM

  Kevin Markman

  May 7, 2026
  4.0
  Place was empty when they opened so we were the first ones to order and they were helpful. Pizza all had blackened edges and looked like personal pizzas. Had cauliflower wings which were cauliflower with wing sauce no breading which were okay. Great view of the lake on a nice day for location.
• KM

  Krista Millian

  Apr 26, 2026
  5.0
  Love the atmosphere on the lake and the service was amazing. Nola and Des are the best.
• JL

  John Lacomba

  Apr 19, 2026
  2.0
  Seated next to a loud fan, my Keuka pizza came with diced extremely hot peppers that weren’t in the ingredients listed. I’m no stranger to spice and heat so it wasn’t a problem but it seemed like an odd choice to leave that off the menu. The Montes Malbec they have on-hand is bitter. My girlfriend’s Honeoye pizza was alright.