MW
Matthew White
4 days ago
The place has a holiday beach vibe and decent food. A bit overpriced but so is everything in this area. Unpretentious.
TD
Tonya D'Agostino
Aug 12, 2026
I've been a regular at COHO since they opened and have always had a positive experience but with Dana at the helm things are even better. Her personality is magnetic and she is a true leader who rolls up her sleeves and works along side the staff to "get the job done". She has put together an amazing team of bartenders and servers and the additon of SINGO and the Sunday brunch were great additions.
BT
Brad Taylor-White
Aug 12, 2026
10/10 — Fantastic pizza, service, and lakeside setting
We absolutely loved our experience at COHO Pizza & Wine Bar! We were lucky enough to sit outside, and the lakeside setting was beautiful. The service was also top-notch, and our server took such great care of us. She answered all of our questions and went above and beyond with some special requests, making everything feel completely effortless. We wish we could remember her name, but hopefully the restaurant can identify her through the Resy reservation attached to our table!
And the pizza was truly 10/10. The dough was incredible, as were the sauce, cheese, and toppings. We also loved that there were great non-pizza options, including a salad that was perfect for sharing, and we especially appreciated having the option of chilled red wine.
Overall, we absolutely loved COHO. 10/10 food, service, and atmosphere. We would happily come back and highly recommend it!
JG
Jonathan Glavy
Aug 11, 2026
I visited Canandaigua for a bachelorette trip and came across Coho Pizza & Wine Bar. Since we had a large party of 15, I called ahead to make a reservation. The employee I spoke with even had a manager come on the phone to approve the reservation because of our group size. The day before, I received a text asking me to confirm the reservation, which I did.
Unfortunately, when we arrived on time for our reservation, we were told there would be a wait but weren’t given an estimated time. We completely understood that it can take some time to get a table ready for a large group. However, we then overheard that it could take an HOUR to seat us. Ultimately, we were seated 1 hour and 1 minute after our original reservation time.
I understand that large groups can be difficult to accommodate, but that’s also why I made the reservation ahead of time, received manager approval, and confirmed it the day before. Waiting over an hour despite doing all of that was extremely frustrating, especially for a bachelorette group that had other plans scheduled afterward.
To their credit, they did try to make things right by discounting our first round of drinks, which we appreciated. The food and drinks were also very good once we were seated.
I mainly wanted to share this for anyone considering Coho with a large group. If you have plans afterward or are working with a schedule, I would be cautious about relying on your reservation time. The food and drinks were great, but the reservation experience for our group was disappointing.
SC
Scott Conking
Aug 8, 2026
Terrible service. Empty tables but long waits even with a reservation. They over book. Embarrassing to bring out of town guests.