Tony's Brooklyn Pizza

Reviews

• MJ

  Milton Ruperto Jr

  5 days ago
  5.0
  The best pizza and Italian food in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. These guys go way beyond to service you and to make you feel as family. I totally and highly recommend Tony's for your daily lunch or dinner.
• SG

  Sergio Gutierrez

  Aug 3, 2026
  5.0
  Today I ordered a calzone and it was as good as the ones I got in Isola di Capri, I was impressed. The dipping sauce so delicious specially compared to other places in the Neighborhood, where they just mix it up with water. Thanks a lot If Carmines is packed, this is a better option!
• RB

  Robert Burak

  Jul 15, 2026
  4.0
  Good pizza. Better than carmines. But service here can be quite bizarre. Went in last night at 10:43, which is 17 minutes before closing. Ordered two cheese slices and paid cash. Was charged $11. Menu says it's $4 a slice. So I was clearly overcharged by a couple bucks ... on food they'd likely end up giving away (the stools already up so it was takeout only on limited selection). When I asked about price discrepancy I was told by the young woman working, "we only work here." So I guess its managements policy to overcharge and the staff just follows orders? Again, bizarre. I invite management to verify what I am saying - i was there July 14th at approximately 10:45. I was the only customer. There should be a cash transaction for $11 at that time.
• DS

  Domingo soyluna

  Jul 7, 2026
  1.0
  l ordered a Vodka slice and I added pepperoni. This burnt pizza was $10.91, it was disgusting. Expensive and burnt. Never going back to this place. Carmines across the street was closed that is why I came to this spot because I wanted a good decent slice of pizza. Worst decision I had!
• CK

  CorreyHope Kustin

  Jul 2, 2026
  1.0
  The pizza was burnt and you know not fresh! The day was extremely hot and the inside was like an oven. I should have gone with my instinct to leave. Gave the local place the opportunity for my business. Since it was so hot I asked for a cup of ice. I was charged $1.04 for a less than half a cup of ice. If I sat in the restaurant would the water be free? Warning ‼ with all the restaurants on graham- never ever again!! The cup was small In response: ice is water/ and if your store didnt parch my throat from the heat- I would not have needed Ice!!! Let the others know you are pathetic!