Prince Street Pizza

Reviews

• UF

  Ubi Maior Film

  3 days ago
  1.0
  Terrible. The worst pizza I’ve had in New York in months. The sauce was sweet and full of sugar; the dough was soft and rubbery. A terrible experience. I wouldn't even give it to my worst enemy. And 7$ for a slice of Pepperoni. I spent 35 dollars for 5 slices of pizza. Totally insane.
• SS

  Sim_Simma

  Oct 8, 2026
  5.0
  Whole staff was warm and pleasant pizza was also delicious, my daughter and I devoured. Excellent I would highly recommend.
• JP

  Jordan Palmer

  Oct 5, 2026
  5.0
  Perfect spot for a late night slice. It's my go-to on Saturday and the cookies shouldn't be slept on either!
• KA

  Kratos Of The Ascended

  Sep 29, 2026
  5.0
  So, I'd never been to Brooklyn, until today. Which is pretty ridiculous having lived in NY my whole life. But, being a big fan of Gears of War I simply couldn't miss out on the once in a lifetime opportunity to get the EMERGENCE PIZZA PIE. Travelled two hours via the MTA and Subways and after arriving - God was it worth it. AN ENORMOUS, EMERGING SHOUTOUT TO BEATRICE, ABID, AND LOUIE for an AMAZING EXPERIENCE. NOT ONLY FOR A MAKING A LIFELONG GEARS FAN'S DAY, BUT FOR MY FIRST SLICE OF BROOKLYN PIZZA. Y'all will ONE-HUNDRED PERCENT see me again soon. THANK YOU SO MUCH!! YOU ARE AWESOME! - Danny T from Upstate
• SP

  Sam Pecoraro

  Sep 17, 2026
  1.0
  Ordered delivery and this is how it came. Inedible, ended up tossing it and going out to eat. Emailed prince street and never heard back. $80 for this btw.