AA
Amanda Addis
Oct 7, 2026
As someone who is from Bay Ridge, born & bred, Pegasus has always been a go-to. Service is always excellent, and it's a great little Bay Ridge spot.
Today, however, I was super disappointed in the food. I went in with my husband & brother - brother and I ordered yogurt bowls, husband ordered a prosciutto avocado benedict. We also ordered a peaches & cream french toast for the table, with the cream on the side.
Husband said his food was fine, but as someone who loves "sit down breakfast," as he calls it, he was not at all impressed and afterwards said we should have gone elsewhere. Brother liked his yogurt bowl well enough, while I felt it was incredibly thick (don't come at me about greek yogurt, I'm literally greek.) There was very little honey on the yogurt, so we asked for more and I was disappointed to see it was a Kraft honey in small packets. In all honesty, it wasn't good and was annoying to get out of the container and into the yogurt. But, not the end of the world. The french toast also came with Kraft maple syrup. The syrup was, imo, disgusting and left a horrible after taste. The mascarpone cream helped a bit but ultimately none of us could eat much of it. The peaches were also of the canned variety and very sugary.
We also all ordered drinks - brother loved his freshly squeezed OJ, husband had coffee, my hot chocolate was very watered down and, again, not worth drinking more than a few sips.
Overall, I've known Pegasus to be GREAT. I want it to be GREAT. Today was very mid, and that's me being nice. Will I go back to Pegasus? Likely (even though I no longer live in Brooklyn). Will I hope for better? Absolutely.