Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• JS

  Jakobe smitherson

  2 days ago
  1.0
  me and my brother ordered 4 boxes of pizza and the employee gave away 2 boxes and refused to make the 2 boxes we payed for.
• GG

  George G

  Sep 21, 2026
  1.0
  This place might need to be shut down or new managment. Everytime k order a pepperoni large pie or anything from here.... the opposite comes not sure what the guys issue is or just simply can't read.
• EH

  Ethan Hummel

  Sep 18, 2026
  3.0
  Papa Johns Pizza is a familiar national chain option for quick carryout or late-night delivery. Conveniently located on Neptune Avenue, it serves up their signature pizza pies, garlic dipping sauce, chicken wings, and side snacks. The menu offers plenty of customization with various crust options and topping combinations, making it an easy pick for group gatherings or casual pizza nights. However, overall experiences can vary depending on peak order times-delivery times occasionally stretch longer during busy evenings, and pie consistency can be a bit hit-or-miss. For a convenient, reliable, and recognizable standard pizza fix when you need quick service or delivery, it gets the job done.
• DR

  Daniella Rijo

  Aug 20, 2026
  3.0
  Stopped here before our beach day. The employee who took our order was really nice and friendly, so shoutout to him! 🙌🏽 The only thing I didn’t like was the amount of flies hanging around the inside of the service window. A few of them looked like they were slowly dying, which definitely wasn’t the most pleasant thing to see. 🪰😩 The kids said the pizza was fine. As for the garlic Parmesan wings… I probably wouldn’t order those again. They were absolutely drenched in butter. 🧈😂 But overall, it’s Papa Johns—what do we really expect? 😂🍕 Now for the crazy part… I stepped out of the pizzeria for literally two seconds to grab something from the store. I come back and there’s a man cornering my child inside the pizzeria, trying to sell her stolen goods. 😳 Thankfully Mom came to save the day! 😂✋🏽 The guy behind the counter was just minding his business and didn’t seem to notice what was going on. Definitely an interesting experience before heading to the beach! 🌊
• KK

  Kriss

  Aug 2, 2026
  5.0
  Fast fresh pizza. I tried both delivery and carryout, I must say their service is fast and the pizza stays fresh, hot and delicious. Yum.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza