Sofia's Pizza

Reviews

• TT

  Tiara

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Manager Angelo was absolutely amazing! From the moment we walked in, he provided exceptional customer service and genuine hospitality. He was friendly, attentive, welcoming, and made sure we had a great experience. The shop is small, cute, clean, and has such a nice, relaxed vibe. The food was fresh, flavorful, and great quality. Everything tasted freshly prepared, and the service matched the quality of the food. The staff was great all around, and the chef, Miguel, was especially nice as well. You can tell this is a team that cares about both the food they serve and the people they serve it to. Fresh food, quality service, good energy, and genuine hospitality. Angelo and Miguel are definitely assets to this establishment. We will absolutely be back! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
• ME

  Mariah Estrada

  Aug 8, 2026
  5.0
  Initially came to get this special but ended up getting the family special Large Pizza, wings, fries, & soda for only $30 plus a Philly cheesesteak w/fries for $10 more. Angelo greeted us and took our order, he was very nice & had great customer service. 10/10 stop by & give a try. Very affordable!
• RB

  riley bates

  Jul 29, 2026
  5.0
  Most underrated pizza spot in town! Customer service 10/10 food 10/10. Angelo was super nice at pick up. When I called in an order they said it be ready in 20 min I got there in an 10-15 and it was already ready. They make HUGE slices of pizza and huge pizzas too he showed me all the different sizes they offer. And the pizza is the best. The crust is light and airy not overly chewy. Still stable enough to where the pizza slice doesn't just fall apart when you pick it up. Tastes like a traditional New York pizza. Greasy but not overly greasy. Perfect ratio of sauce cheese and toppings. Oh and I forgot the best part: the price is unbeatable!! Large pep for under 12 dollars????? No body offers that deal at that quality.
• EU

  email user

  Jul 25, 2026
  4.0
  Small independent pizza shop in business for over 25 years. Mostly a carry out place, 1 small 2 person table inside, 2 tables outside. Good price for a large 2 topping pizza $13.99, tasted good, only issue was not enough pizza sauce, but that may have just been an oversight by the very busy cook today. Large selection of canned sodas and Jarritos soda falvors in glass bottles. They have nice desserts- milkshakes, ice cream, cheesecake, cannolis. They also have single pizza slice specials. They get busy during lunch and dinner so there's a 15+ minute wait if you order in person and not ahead. This place is affordable, but still offers good quality.
• TS

  The North Star

  Jul 24, 2026
  1.0
  The first time I came here was about a month ago for the Pick Up Special. I was told there'd be a 15 minute wait and it took almost 25 minutes for two slices of pepperoni pizza. The customer service was just O.K. I thought I'd give them another try so I went back today for a second time. I ordered a pizza/wings special and was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. I doubted this, because of my first experience, so I walked around the plaza and even talked for a long time with a shop owner (whom I'll be leaving a great review for!) to give the pizza shop extra time. After half an hour, I go back to the pizza shop and my order is still not ready. I wait for longer and I mention that this is the second time I've been here and I'm told "15 minutes" but it's always longer. Well, the manager went off on me and started carrying on, "C'mon, man! It's hot! We're busy! We're all doing our best!" I let him go off and just listened to the excuses he was rattling off. Then I made him aware that this was my second time here with the same experience. Well, that just REALLY set him off and he told me how I should be respectful to him for feeding me (as if he was doing me charity) and that I was being condescending. "Excuse me? Sir, I haven't insulted anyone or called anyone names. I'm telling you about the service." He remained combative and aggressive. Then, in a hateful and angry manner, he yells, "HEY! GOD BLESS YOU, ALL RIGHT?!!!" as I'm walking out. A customer looks at me in complete shock and disbelief at how the shop owner/manager was losing his temper at me. I shook my head at the customer and just told him to be careful. I will not be going back here for any reason at all because of the poor customer service, the anger and entitlement of the owner/manager, the list of excuses, etc. The correct thing to do would have been to say, "I apologize for another long wait time. We'll improve on that. Thank you." This would've made me forget all about it and continue to support this shop. I will also tell family, friends, co-workers, and acquaintances to stay away from this place by word of mouth. I recommend the same to you. Thanks. EDIT: Owner called me on the phone, lied and said he apologized to me (he never apologized to me), asked me where I work (VERY weird), then condescended to me and told me that I probably have no job (rude and unnecessary to insult customers). I let him go off and talk all he wanted. Then he ends with, "And that's what I think about you!" I simply said, "Ok." and he hangs up on me. I wish you well, man.