Secret Pizza

Reviews

• DH

  Derek Hemsley

  3 days ago
  5.0
  This is the spot for pizza. Decently priced and is close to NY pizza. They must buy New York water or something because this stuff is my go to place anytime I'm in town. Not a lot of sitting area is the only down side.
• SS

  Shelly Straub

  Aug 27, 2026
  5.0
  Authentic NEW YORK hand tossed thin and crispy pizza to perfection! I really enjoyed the hunt to find this secret pizza but more than that I enjoyed the pizza!!! Came back once more before leaving town! I shared two slices of cheese and white and had them split it so we could each have half! Couldn’t say which one I liked better. Love them both!!!
• JT

  J T

  Aug 19, 2026
  5.0
  I mean- your paying for the speakeasy pizza experience. The pizza is a small slice for $7. The glass of wine is huge- prob 12 ounces and is $6. Good wine find. Fun pizza find! Def worth it. Across from beauty and Essex in cosmopolitan (basically…. More diagonal than across)
• JG

  Jay Gee

  Aug 18, 2026
  4.0
  Well, it’s pizza. I’m not completely sure it’s a secret!!! The concept is fine and the location is cool. I thought the staff was really nice. The pizza is nothing I haven’t had before in New York or even locally, but it was tasty and well done. Be aware there is very limited seating so you’re either gonna stand up or have to take it elsewhere. I’m sure the people in a fancy restaurant really appreciate you eating pizza in the lobby.!!
• RA

  R “Rudy” Aguilar

  Aug 15, 2026
  2.0
  This was my second visit. The first prior to a week long visit in Manhattan: eating pizza there, I have a better reference for great NYC style pizza slices. I brought my buddy hoping he would enjoy a secret slice. Unfortunately the choices were very limited and what we chose was not worth the $10. There was very little sauce to begin with and that is what makes or breaks a good slice. We tried a new place across the street next to In N Out on the roof top of BLVD. Now that was outstanding!