Prince Street Pizza

Reviews

• RM

  Robyn Moore

  May 12, 2026
  5.0
  It’s New York style pizza with New York style service. For instance, they may not be giving you an ear to ear grin but they’ll fix any problem quickly and you’ll get what you asked for in a timely manner. For instance, some random customer had thrown a whole roll of toilet paper inside the toilet bowl. There was no plunger or bowl cleaner for me to handle it myself so I asked one of the guys out front and within a couple minutes, they came by with thick gloves on, heaved the roll into the trash and went on about their business. No fuss, no muss- problem handled. Now about the food- it was good!! I got the Margherita and naughty slices. Others got four cheese, boozy and the greens one. All delicious! Would go there again for sure. Good sized slices too, was full after 1 1/2 slices. And good location!!
• EE

  evelyncravenZUMBA

  May 10, 2026
  5.0
  The first time I ever tried Prince Street Pizza was when we visited New York City a few years ago. My husband and I were so thrilled when we saw the location at the Durango Casino and now this one on Eastern and Serene . (This one is closer to our house) what I love about Prince Street pizza slices is they are not overpowered or overwhelmed with a heavy sauce. I prefer a crispy chewy crust, light sauce, and good flavor. My favorite is the Fancy Prince and pepperoni slice Which I always order for their lunch special.** The Green Machine is notable too. Ask the helpful employees for a recommendation if you need help If you haven’t tried Prince St.Pizza yet, do yourself a favor and get a slice
• CM

  Christian Mele

  May 9, 2026
  1.0
  I was going to a friends house to hangout with some people. 6 or so at most. I order a “full” sheet of pizza from this place for ~$45 (literally one topping). I get there to pickup and it’s tiny. Less than a normal large pie would be anywhere else, I could literally eat it between 2 people. You go to a place like Naked City Pizza and order a “full” sheet for ~$50 and it’s enough to feed 10 people. I literally had to stop somewhere else to get more food. Guy was rude, pizza was mediocre. Skip it.
• DM

  Daniel Mar

  May 5, 2026
  5.0
  First time in and left feeling like King at Prince Street! I tried four of their fresh scratch made pies, none of which disappointed. Feeling slick n adventurous I even tried their hamburger pie which I strongly recommend if you are looking for a less greasy-lighter alternative to a real burger. Don’t skip the lettuce sprinkle, it adds a fresh crunchy texture. Every recipe gave true space to the individual ingredients; you can actually taste all the flavors intended! From the fresh basil, to the smoked meats n cheeses, they are well balanced on that crispy and soft thin crust. Definitely recommend to anyone looking to elevate the usual pizza game. Sorry about not posting photos, the food was in a hurry to be devoured.
• LC

  L Car

  May 4, 2026
  5.0
  Pizza was great! Ordered the Naughty Pie for pick up. Was done on time, place was clean, staff was friendly. Casual pizza spot. We’ve had Prince St. in Westlake and was hoping it was just as good as when we’ve had it there.. the reviews were a little concerning but we wanted to give it try and glad we did! Unfortunately, I just can’t trust Vegas food reviews whether they’re good or bad. I can’t speak for pizza by the slice as we haven’t tried that yet but the whole pie we ordered was great and as good as we’d remembered. Thank you!