Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• GL

  Gilbert Lorenz

  May 4, 2026
  2.0
  The reason why I wrote this review… I received an email regarding $10 in papa dough expiring on 5/03/2026. I decided to let it expire and turned down free food because I know better than to set myself up for disappointment again. The last two times I ordered from Papa Johns the pizza dough was tasteless, the bone out chicken had more breading than chicken and they used Door Dash for delivery. Door Dash didn’t ring the doorbell and hand me my food as instructed and didn’t even notify when they dropped off the food and let it sit outside for half an hour to get cold. Why would I pay for substandard food and substandard delivery service again when they already proved they can’t get it right the first time…or second time? There is no third with me. I stopped ordering out nine months ago and have no intentions of ordering out from anywhere again. In conclusion, I gave two stars because I ate some of the food and management was understanding and did what they could do to make it right.
• AS

  Alexia Stasinopoulos

  Apr 3, 2026
  3.0
  Love Papa Johns but they are always short handed and behind with orders..Seem to need more help/employees. Always a wait for this place.
• DS

  Diane Sheehan

  Jan 10, 2026
  5.0
  Very polite and friendly. Service was prompt and the food was very delicious.
• BA

  Bob-Karim Anderson-Ahmed

  Nov 30, 2025
  5.0
  Best Papa John’s location in NM I have been to. They’re never stingy on toppings and ingredients, and they always do their best to make hungry customers happy. Evenly proportioned pizzas and are very careful & respectful of dietary restrictions.
• CB

  Colleen Bishop

  Nov 26, 2025
  1.0
  Not sure how hard it is to read a description of a pizza order requested. My pizza wasn't even edible.