Johnny G's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Reviews

• RN

  Rosie N

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Our first time here, and we definitely will be returning. My husband had the chicken parm and truly enjoyed it, portion was more than he expected and took half of it home. I had a small chicken parm sandwich, it was delicious 😋. We highly recommend Johnny G's
• ES

  Emma Scribellito

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Pizza places in Tom River are a dime a dozen but I literally drive out of my way to the silverton section of TR to get my pizza from here. The pies are always top notch and the dinners are out of this world and you can’t beat the prices. Never had a bad meal here. What really drives at home for me, though, is how nice the people that work there are. I never mind waiting for my pies if they are busy because the staff is always so nice even if they’re in the weeds, you would never know it because they always have a smile on their face. Tonight, their main dining room was popping, and all their employees were running around And if they were frazzled, you couldn’t tell because everyone was just so kind.
• JG

  John Glynn

  Jun 2, 2026
  4.0
  Not bad. My first time there. Will give it a try againl
• MM

  Moe

  May 16, 2026
  5.0
  4.3??? Are you serious? Have you even tried their one of a kind Garlic Knot Eggplant Sandwich? I would crawl across shattered glass for this sandwich. I would leap off a cliff and break both legs just to have someone lower one down to me on a rope. I would send a monkey to the moon and back just so I could announce to humanity that there is absolutely nothing on Earth that tastes better than this sandwich. A 4.3? No. YOU are a 4.3. This thing is a 10 out of 10 thousand. I’m convinced God created the sandwich first, looked down upon mankind, and whispered into the creator’s dreams... "My child... build this." Service? The goth chick behind the counter was awesome. She laughed at my joke and made me feel like an actual human being instead of another number in line. That's rare these days. Not your typical dead eyed teenage keyboard drone running on autopilot. Atmosphere? Busy as hell... and honestly that makes it more impressive. She still took the time to smile. Give her another dollar an hour immediately because she is carrying morale on her shoulders and she gathered my business in one honest gesture. Food? Godlike. Service? Angelic. This establishment is less of a restaurant and more of a divine event. Go here and love it. The Wizard has spoken.
• JE

  jim ellis

  May 7, 2026
  1.0
  I remember why I stopped going here once I opened my pizza box. Impossible to pick up a slice just a soggy mess.