WD
WHIZDEE DOLBRUS
May 22, 2026
Every time I order from here the food is good. But be very wary of online ordering. They will give you the wrong items or fail to give you the items you ordered without a second thought. Always check your food before you leave the door.
JG
Joseph Guidice
Apr 29, 2026
Bagels are decent but isn’t ran properly , go into any bagel store in nyc , they have someone just for buttering or cream cheese bagels so you’re in and out . The wait for a bagel with butter is just as long as an egg sandwich ..this shouldnt be
MS
Michelle Spevak
Mar 13, 2026
If you’re anywhere near Spotswood, you have to stop at Bagel One. This place is an absolute gem.
Their French Toast bagels are incredible—perfectly sweet, soft on the inside with just the right texture. And the Cinnamon Raisin bagels with powdered sugar are next level. Warm, fragrant, and lightly dusted so every bite tastes like a treat.
Lunch here is just as impressive. The gyros are packed with flavor, the tuna melts are served on perfectly crispy buttered bread with gooey, melty cheese, and the chicken quesadillas are absolutely massive—loaded with fresh ingredients and cooked perfectly.
Everything tastes fresh, the portions are generous, and you can tell they take pride in what they make. It’s the kind of place you visit once and immediately start planning your next trip back.
Bagel One is easily one of the best breakfast and lunch spots in the area. Highly recommend!
LK
Lennon JK Kane
Feb 16, 2026
super overpriced bagels that are hard as a rock and super stale. i went there and there was multiple bagel options that i couldn’t get.i definitely recommend never going to this place ever!
AC
Amilcar Colon
Jan 27, 2026
Best spot in the area for Bagels and breakfast Sandwiches.