Went in the middle of the day so the place was empty. Decor is super cool and fits the vibe. Food was absolutely delicious. The only thing I didn’t love was the coleslaw, which had a lot of celery seed in it. Some people love it that way I’m just not one of them. The Maine lobster roll was great and the mini lobster rolls were also fantastic.
I have always LOVED the food here, its delicious, fresh and when delivered EXCELLENT. Last night I had a problem with my Gift Card going through on the app and I couldn't get it to work. I called Short Hills, and the woman (I am sorry I didn't get her name) was FANTASTIC!!! She helped me, got her manager involved, worked with me until she got it to work. Customer Service was AMAZING. I hope the owners read this and cudos to the woman, because she deserves it, and the entire staff that helped me. A restaurant that has delicious food AND good customer service, is A+++++ in my book!
SC
stephen chiang
Oct 3, 2026
Middle-Aged ex-NYC-turned-Suburban Asian Dad Seeks Affordable Seafood-Oriented Fix w/minimal Hassle & Pretentiousness.
He find Jacks, and it worked.
Thus Plusses:
- raw oysters great. The Kumamoto delivered reasonably well
- Fish sandwich: blackened grouper w arugula and buttered bun plus cold slaw and tarter - holy moly that was pretty good for $23
- Peel Shrimp: hot, salty, buttered/oiled. Pretty good
- not crowded; liked the laid back vibe and lack of crowding. It was not deserted this Saturday evening, but not overpopulated. So just right.
- we ordered a lot for 2 (guy hunger, 1 guy was a teenager which technically counts as a bear): 2 entrees, raw oysters, clam chowder, peeled shrimp. Stomachs stuffed, wallet not depleted. I think the total was just over $100
- Son said “this was great. I’d come back”. Happy kid = Happy parent = repeat custy
- BYOB
The OK & any ideas:
- Manhattan clam chowder: first, thank you for having this. Too many places only serve New England which is usually a crème orgy. Not great if you’re allergic to fat or cream. Unfort today was a bit salty. But it was still hearty w a lot of “stuff” in it
- Salmon entre: son ordered it. Good portions. He liked. I tasted and it was fine. Would be awesome if they seared it!
- if you invest in finer wine glasses for those bringing their bottle, the psychological upgrade could be real. Get more up to date glasses w thinner thickness rim that makes a good sound when you toast.
Recap:
- Reliable laid-back seafood shack w good portions, variety, and sustainable pricing. Maybe not first date spot (unless I was in high school), but certainly if you’re safely togeth w someone and want something easy and casual while needing to scratch a seafood itch.
AR
Aleksandr Rubinshteyn
Sep 24, 2026
Not a budget place but worth every penny. Lobster roll is real deal. They allow BYOW which is nice. The place was not crowded at all, we were the only ones on Sunday night.
Life changing rice pudding, Avi was very friendly and a great server. Looking forward to stopping by again.