Love this unique tucked away restaurant the food is amazing the staff amazing. I've been there 5 times and look forward to the next. They don't disappoint!! Prices are not gauging.
So easy to place online order for delicious steak and seafood, then have it delivered on time! Steaks are high quality, tender and cooked as ordered. Grill oysters=outstanding; so is the lobster. Will definitely order from Jack’s again.
We had the Conneticut lobster roll, lobster Mac and cheese, and the lobster bomb. All the dishes were packed with lobster! The best dish out of all the them was the lobster bomb! It was so DELICIOUS! The sourdough bread tasted so good soaked in the lobster bisque soup! I’d definitely come back in to order it again. The lobster roll was good, but it could have been better if had more hot drawn butter. The lobster Mac and cheese was ok/good, but not good enough to order again. One thing disappointing was that all of our entrees were served lukewarm. Next time I come I will tell them prior to make sure the entrees are served hot. For dessert we had the dulce de leche cheesecake and the Mississippi mud pie. The cheesecake was disappointing. It wasn’t good except the dulce de leche on top. The Mississippi mud pie was FANTASTIC! It was rich and chocolaty all throughout. We loved it! I recommend Jack’s Surf & Turf in Short Hills!
Had an amazing dinner!! Our waitress, BB, was awesome! She was super sweet, personable, and very attentive. The food was soooo good! BB made an already great evening even better! Can’t wait to visit again! BB, we’ll be sure to keep it quiet on creek! (Inside joke)
RJ
Ramon Jimenez
Jul 25, 2026
This is a wonderful spot to dine for any occasion. From the moment we walked in there was a warm, friendly atmosphere. The host was very welcoming and was able to accomodate all our needs. Our waitress, Brianna (sorry if spelled incorrectly), was absolutely wonderful. She was knowledgeable of the entire menu and was able to make recommendations without hesitation. She had a wonderful, friendly and energetic demeanor. We also met Greg who frequently checked in on us. Everyone else who helped bring our food were also amazing and we couldn't have asked for better service. Every single dish that we ordered, from the appetizers to our main entrees were exceptional. This was a very memorable experience for us and we would not hesitate to come back.