Island Beach Fish Company

Reviews

• TD

  Tim D

  Sep 15, 2026
  1.0
  Avoid. They were made aware of problems with my order, and didn't rectify it or respond to my email.
• BD

  Brian Dowd

  Sep 8, 2026
  5.0
  First time to the outdoor bar and restaurant area. We had a table of 4, all of us enjoyed our cocktails and food. Great atmosphere and service was on point.
• PP

  Peace

  Sep 8, 2026
  1.0
  Horrible experience!! Will never ever go back and that’s saying something when you live only 2 blocks away!! Our reservation was for 5:45. We arrived at 5:40 and were seated quickly. However, we didn’t get our entrees until 6:35!! We were so disgusted that we had boxed up and brought it home. It would’ve been a wonderful celebration for my husband’s birthday. It was the worst birthday ever! Food was disappointing and not worth the money, boardwalk food at more than 50% cheaper is better. Four one inch small/medium scallops for $20, tasty but a rip off! We thought it was a cool, cute looking place, but the other issue is the uncomfortable seats! Most have no backs, and the ones that do are EXTREMELY uncomfortable. Also, even though they have umbrellas, the sun was in our eyes. Never ever going back!!
• TP

  Tat P

  Sep 5, 2026
  2.0
  Concession stand type food that takes unreasonably long. Had to remind about utensils and tartar sauce which was part of the entrees. Drinks are okay - not great. Live music would be nice if I could hear it over the loud tipsy crowd. 👎
• RK

  Rachel Kelly

  Aug 30, 2026
  5.0
  We had a great experience! I had gone previously and this time brought my kids, husband and dog. Our server was super accommodating and friendly and everything came out accurately and tasted great! The smashburger was delicious and the kids loved the mozzarella sticks, the Bavarian pretzel and the chicken fingers and fries. Definitely worth a visit!

Frequently Asked Questions About Island Beach Fish Company