Shore Fresh Seafood Market & Restaurant

Reviews

• JR

  Jozette Rodriguez

  2 days ago
  1.0
  I ordered oysters on the half shell from Shore Fresh Food Market's raw bar booth at the Belmar Seafood Festival on Saturday 5/16/26 and what arrived on my plate was more dirt than oyster. They were completely unrinsed absolutely disgusting and unacceptable for raw shellfish. Basic food prep 101. To make matters worse, the hot sauce and condiments were facing inward toward the workers, making them nearly impossible for customers to reach. When I asked for assistance, the response I got was "oh well, make it work," followed by laughter. I was met with complete dismissal and mockery instead of basic human decency. The customer service here is the worst I have ever experienced. These young men behind the counter have zero professionalism, zero care for the people they are serving, and clearly zero standards for food hygiene. A raw bar serving dirty, unrinsed oysters is not just bad service it's a health concern. An absolute disgrace. Do not waste your money here.
• DM

  David Murray

  3 days ago
  3.0
  I am a longtime customer who loves Shore Fresh at both locations. My wife and I always look forward to the best seafood and fresh cut fries on the Jersey Shore. They have changed the fries to shoe string fry. Not a fan, please bring back the original delicious cut French fry. Dave M.
• FC

  Falon Cotton

  6 days ago
  4.0
  Always fresh food here and has great taste! However, if an item is 86’d there should be a notification of the substitution. We ordered our dinners with wild rice. We received yellow rice. Small item but those are the things that make a difference. Thanks guys!
• EW

  edward wittles

  May 12, 2026
  5.0
  Ordered for delivery - good service - enjoyed our order -food was very good and large quanity in dishes - have eaten at the restraurant many times through the years first time had it delivered - very pleased will do this again- Keep up the good service
• HH

  Happy Harry

  May 12, 2026
  5.0
  Sorry to have to give one stars in all areas. One year ago my wife and I had a great experience here. Serious restaurants know you are judged in three areas! Food, cost and service! Working hard in those areas will always bring customers back. Our experience with our last visit exhibited cold soup, expensive fish dinner that had been baked to the plate making it difficult to eat. A very inconsiderate radio blast that made no sense at all! It did accomplish the leaving of another customer. I truly hope the owners use this feedback and make adjustments! We experienced their best and know they are better than this experience.

Frequently Asked Questions About Shore Fresh Seafood Market & Restaurant