Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

Reviews

• RB

  Robert-Scott Bannersglare

  Jun 9, 2026
  4.0
  I have not journeyed to Lincroft in quite a while ever since I went to Brookdale Community College. The trip down memory lane also led me to Lincroft Plaza. Brand: 4/5 Atlantic Bagel is a small chain in the New Jersey area, specifically the shore region. This one was located in Lincroft Plaza in Lincroft. Its logo has a simple design, letting you know what to expect, with the logo having a simple ABC in black, standard font. The interior retains that rustic, small town look, with the wooden floors and the brick walls. Atmosphere: 3/5 I noticed that the beverages section had doors that did not slide by itself, leaving me to close it myself. The loud music did have me repeat my order. Nonetheless, I had plenty of space to choose from, and the food selection involved many breakfast offerings on the screens above. Food: 5/5 I ordered the Bambino, their signature bagel sandwich with pork rolls, onion, cheese omelette, bacon, sausage, and potato bits, between my choice of a sesame seed bagel. I will say such a flavor-packed sandwich definitely fits as a signature sandwich. Any taste the onions probably had a subtle flavor to it, since I did not taste them compared to the hearty potatoes, the spicy pork roll, and the warm cheese. While the omelettes did slide out of the sandwich, the bagel itself managed to hold together. I can see how such a breakfast sandwich can represent Atlantic Bagel. I will say that I had similar breakfast sandwiches, in the past and I cannot say that this one had a strong impression on me. I will say that the bagels set it apart from the others, and it filled me throughout the day. The service prepared the sandwich well, and it had a good amount of heat to it. Service: 5/5 They care for their food, while also caring for their relationship with their customers. I had no issues waiting for my order, despite the late morning. They gave me a pretty good first impression of the establishment. Nothing about it interfered too much with the service. Cost: 3/5 Taking into consideration every aspect of Atlantic Bagel Lincroft, I will say that they managed to work as a small chain. While I would have reluctance returning, I would not say I hated the experiencing going there. The flavor-jammed Bambino made the trip to Lincroft Plaza worth it out of every other aspect. I cannot say I have any personal suggestions, though I would loosely suggest that they maintain an identity that separates them from other breakfast eateries, whether through their branding or advertising their signature dishes more. If I do find myself in Lincroft Plaza again, I would definitely try their other signature dishes. Rating: 4/5 Stars While I can say that Atlantic Bagel retains a homey standing in Lincroft, it only does so much. I can see how it will last a while in the future, though I do not know if I would return. Recommend To… Anyone in Lincroft looking for a breakfast that will last them throughout the day.
• AR

  Alyssa Rivers

  Jun 3, 2026
  3.0
  Seriously disappointed. I usually go to the location on 35 but I was in lincroft today so I decided to give it a try. I asked for my bacon to be well done and it was so floppy it was almost raw. I will not be returning to this location. However, the location on 35 in red bank always gets my order perfect so I won't hold it against the company.
• BM

  Branden M

  Apr 12, 2026
  3.0
  The flavor of these bagels was solid. However the texture didn't quite hit the mark for me. Compared to other local spots, these bagels were on the smaller side and lacked that signature soft, pillowy interior I was looking for. I ordered two plain and two everything bagels, and while the taste was decent, they were a bit denser and tougher than the fluffy, oversized bagels you typically find in the area.
• SS

  Shawn Spain

  Mar 21, 2026
  1.0
  I went out of my way to come here. It was 6:55 and was denied service because they open at 7. I own a restaurant and would never turn down a customer. I will NEVER COME BACK…
• MS

  Matt Shaw

  Jan 31, 2026
  5.0
  Just took my daughters in last week for their first jersey bagel and they loved it! Staff was so friendly! Talked with Jessica and she was great to my kids. Will come back next time I’m in town