A & F Italian Specialties Market

Reviews

• PK

  Peter Koulikourdis

  Aug 10, 2026
  5.0
  Fresh baked bread, cold cuts, steaks cut to order and many prepared foods, are delicious. Im told Fresh pizza and and espresso machine are soon to come. The owner, Frankie (from Staten Island) is warm friendly and entertaining! Will definitely go back.
• MS

  Mike Santi

  Jul 28, 2026
  5.0
  I can't ask for anything better! Food is outrageous, great cuts of meat, bread and mooz are super fresh. People are friendly and take pride in their service. And, The Uncle Nookey sandwich was over the top! Old style Brooklyn.
• ND

  Nancy DeCapua

  Jul 22, 2026
  5.0
  I love this place. They got great food, especially the prosciutto bread. Everything I've bought in there is fresh and delicious. So I give A&F Italian Market. Five stars. five stars.
• MS

  Marisa Saitta

  Jul 17, 2026
  5.0
  Been here several times since they opened and have nothing but good to say about the place. The bread is absolutely delicious. If you’re looking for a sandwich spot, this is your place! As someone from north Jersey, the mozz is fantastic. Everything is authentic and fresh unlike another Italian delis in the area that sell cookies from December in April. Will definitely return.
• BH

  Bill Hults

  Jul 16, 2026
  2.0
  Unfortunately, this was likely a one-and-done visit. Ordered three subs over the phone to pick up: an Italian, a Roast Beef w/ mozz, and the Chicken BLT. Get there to pick up, and it was $101. $101!!!! Nowhere on their online menu does it mention that you're looking at prices for a half a sub - not a whole. That's deceptive. I could almost forgive the outrageous price if these were FAR beyond expectations, but they weren't. They were tasty, but fairly standard. I will say that the bread was fantastic - probably the best part of these subs. But to add insult to injury, our requests weren't met. Asked for sweet peppers, got roasted. Asked for the Italian to be wet, it wasn't. The roast beef was overdone (which can't always be controlled, but still). I strongly suggest that the establishment post ALL of the prices. As a consumer, I'd advise you to ask twice about what you're ordering so you don't get a nasty surprise at the register. Finally, I don't mind paying good money for good food...but if you're going to charge prices like this, it better be perfect.