Very pretty place but that's all it mostly is. Drinks were good, strawberry lemonade and frozen horchata were very flavorful. The wings, mango habenero, were very good, perfectly cooked and tender inside, crispy outside. We ordered the paella, it was runny and bland, some parts were over cooked. We ordered a refill for the water decanter that originally came room temp. The next one that came room temp as well even though other table had ones with ice in theirs, had stuff floating in it and the outside of the bottle was dirty, we asked for a new one and for it to be cold water. The replacement had stuff floating in it too. At that point we just paid and left. Not worth it to go again.
KF
Kerri Ferrante
Jun 20, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely Exceptional Experience at Agave!
While visiting New Jersey, we stumbled upon a true hidden gem — Agave in Flemington — and what an incredible discovery it was!
From the moment we called, we were impressed. They were able to accommodate a party of eight with only an hour’s notice, which was amazing in itself. When we arrived, we were immediately welcomed into a beautifully decorated space with a cozy, intimate atmosphere. The dim lighting created the perfect ambiance, and we loved that they also offered a stunning outdoor patio area that was equally charming and beautifully designed.
The food was absolutely outstanding. Every dish arrived fresh, hot, and clearly made with care. Not only was everything delicious, but the pricing was also very reasonable, making the entire experience even more enjoyable.
What truly set this evening apart, however, was our server, Santiago. He embodied what exceptional customer service should be. He was knowledgeable, attentive, friendly, and went above and beyond in every way possible. Santiago didn’t just serve our table—he helped create an unforgettable experience.
We were celebrating a 21st birthday, and thanks to his kindness and attention to detail, it became so much more than a dinner. It became a memory that will be cherished for a lifetime. In a world where great service can be hard to find, Santiago reminded us what genuine hospitality looks like.
I cannot recommend Agave highly enough. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, enjoying a date night, gathering with family, or simply looking for an amazing meal, this place deserves a visit. We left with full hearts, happy memories, and immense gratitude for the outstanding service and hospitality we received.
Thank you, Agave, and thank you, Santiago, for making our celebration so special. We will absolutely be back whenever we’re in the area!