Manhattan Bagel

Reviews

• AB

  Alex Baranov

  3 days ago
  2.0
  As soon as I walked in I realized this was very corporate and chain like and nothing was going to be freshly made there. The person taking my order was pleasant but he messed up my order and gave me a bacon egg and cheese instead of a sausage egg and cheese like I ordered, but whatever close enough. It genuinely seemed like an honest mistake instead of just not listening. Would suck if you were religious or something and got bacon by accident. The bagel was insultingly small, thinly packed, and everything was so bare bones and dry. It literally tasted like an airport bagel shop. My bacon tasted like beef jerky. All of this could be forgiven if that wasn’t $15 for two skimpy breakfast sandwiches. My mistake for not doing my due diligence before walking in but if you’re hungry sometimes you’re not thinking straight. It made me more upset when I saw all the other options in Bayonne, not sure why anyone would go here. Did not hit the spot at all.
• AF

  Angela F.

  6 days ago
  1.0
  I tried over and over to like their bagels, but it's not happening. I'm disappointed everytime. There bagels taste stale and are very skimpy for the price. If you go to places like Hoboken they charge the same price but offer more for your money, as you can see in the side by side comparison of the bagels. Like I said they are the same price. Also, the cook should be fired for not knowing what an over easy egg is.. that's the basics. I got home to eat my bagel and what do you know, the over easy was egg yolk was all over the wrapper. So much for that over easy..more like All Over Wrapper and the cheese wasnt even melted. They really need to do better, or why bother to stay in business if they are going to disappoint. As you can see from the photos, the first 2 are from Manhattan Bagel and the other 2 are from a popular spot in Hoboken. The difference is the amount it's stuffed with and I also got it scooped out, can you imagine that?!
• WP

  william paull

  May 6, 2026
  1.0
  The place has a weird vibe to it, it seems dirty. I got a large cold brew, i asked for a splash of milk, apparently splash means drown the thing to them, i had to stop the guy pouring milk. What he handed me was a milky abomonation that they didnt even fill to the top, i paid $7 for milk, alot of ice and a tinsy bit of coffee 😅
• LL

  L Lugo

  Mar 17, 2026
  1.0
  We ordered the croissant with egg cheese and spinach it was cold and the hash brown was hard as a rock sound location thumbs down 👎
• RA

  rodney alexandre

  Jan 26, 2026
  5.0
  I love manhattan bagel. I eat there atleast 3 times a week.

Frequently Asked Questions About Manhattan Bagel