Vic & Anthony's Steakhouse

Reviews

• VV

  Victoria

  Jul 1, 2026
  5.0
  Vic and Anthony's is my favorite steakhouse of all time. The food is phenomenal every time, the service is top notch and it's such a cozy atmosphere. We visit Atlantic City once a year and we always make sure we come here. We're from LI, NY and I would travel all the way to AC just to eat here for a night. I've tried many steakhouses in LI, and nothing compares to Vic and Anthony's!! I can't wait to go back!!
• GC

  gage chandler

  Jun 27, 2026
  1.0
  I was extremely disappointed with my experience at Vic & Anthony’s. I ordered the $80 filet cooked medium well, but it arrived raw in the center. I understand mistakes can happen, so I sent it back expecting it to be corrected promptly. Unfortunately, by the time my replacement steak came out, the other seven people in my party had already finished their meals. Instead of enjoying dinner with my family, I was left eating alone. To make matters worse, when they took my steak back, they also took my sides. When my replacement meal finally arrived, they brought me the wrong sides, adding even more frustration to an already poor experience. What was even more disappointing was the way the situation was handled by the general manager. Rather than showing concern or making a genuine effort to resolve the issue, he came across as rude, dismissive, and unprofessional. Customer service is just as important as the food, especially at a restaurant that markets itself as a fine dining establishment. For the prices Vic & Anthony’s charges, I expected exceptional food and service. Instead, I received an undercooked $80 steak, delayed service that left me eating after everyone else, incorrect sides, and poor management. Based on this experience, I can’t recommend dining here.
• TC

  Terry Cox

  Jun 23, 2026
  5.0
  Everything was on point as far as a professional and romantic atmosphere! Friendly greeting from hostess, server and the floor help that poured our water! They brought our food out timely at our pace without us having to say wait a minute while we finish our apps. Definitely a go to place whenever we're in town.
• JS

  Jeff S.

  Jun 22, 2026
  2.0
  We had horrible service. Kathryn took our order then didn’t check on us the entire evening until she saw us waiting for our check way after we had overcooked steaks and over cooked scallops. Had I more time to talk with the front of house manager would have requested something done to correct it. On a $350 meal for 2 and our anniversary, it was a horrible experience. Wish the manager made rounds like they had in the past. Only had brief seconds to speak with him and wasn’t happy he didn’t want to fix things.
• SS

  Sarah S

  May 25, 2026
  5.0
  ​Everything we ordered at Vic and Anthony's was delicious, including the expertly prepared filet mignons, bone marrow, and rich au gratin potatoes. The vanilla gelato pecan roll with caramel sauce was the perfect finale. The service was great, and the entire evening was seamless.

Frequently Asked Questions About Vic & Anthony's Steakhouse