The Colosseum Restaurant

Reviews

• EJ

  Eugene Castello Jr

  1 day ago
  5.0
  What a dream come true. This food is incredible and authentic. They have catered parties for me. Have been going here since you could smoke on the dinning room .
• LS

  Lyndsay Slepoy

  2 days ago
  1.0
  Ordered takeout last night for my husbands birthday. All he wanted all day was lasagna (20.95). It had 0 flavor. My chicken Francese ($26.95) was flavorless and the chicken itself was extremely mushy. We ordered chicken fingers for our daughter, it came with 3 chicken fingers for $15 and no side. For the amount of money paid for this meal, we were extremely disappointed and dissatisfied. Staff was friendly at pickup, just clearly not high quality food for the price they have it marked at.
• MB

  M. B.

  5 days ago
  4.0
  I remember when Chef Annibale Todesca was at the Nettles plaza!! There was a two hour wait on a Friday night and the food was well worth the wait!! He could out-cook any Nonna! Sadly this is no longer the case. We visited this past Friday 8/14 @ 7:45. There was no wait. We were sat immediately. We ordered 2 Caesar salads. Completely unremarkable. They looked good but had no flavor whatsoever. We also ordered the chicken & eggplant parm and the chicken Marsala. The dish that the chicken and eggplant was served on had a huge chip in it. Both the chicken and eggplant were tough and tasteless. The chicken in the Marsala was tender but void of any flavor. When the server checked in with us we didn’t bother to say anything. We didn’t see the point. If you have never experienced the Colosseum at its best, you have no idea how much it has declined. This review is given in the hopes of rekindling the passion that was once evident in the quality of the food we first enjoyed at the Colosseum years ago.
• SG

  Samuel Gagliardi

  Aug 2, 2026
  5.0
  The lobster fra diavalo was very good.
• HS

  habib slaybe

  Jul 18, 2026
  5.0
  The Colosseum have the best marinara sauce you could ever have. I don't believe people complaining about the Colosseum. The food is so good all the time.