My review is solely for the lemon strawberry burst cookie. Wow! It's a BURST indeed! The flavor boom took me by surprise, pleasantly of course. It was soooo good! My intent was to taste test it. My test continued until the cookie was gone. I was hoping I left a crumb in the clear packaging. Alas, it was all gone. Now, I need to go back to Jimmy John's to order a sandwich and some cookies. 😂😂😂😂
SS
Secret Shopper
Jun 27, 2026
I opted not to ever eat at Jimmy John's, since the founder, Jimmy John Liautaud is a Big Game Hunter for sport. But, someone placed a group order for us... The sandwich bread is very, very tiny compared to other sub sandwich places. I paid over $20 for a small sandwich, chips, and drink, without a pickle.
EG
Ebony Garner
Jun 13, 2026
Trey is Amazing! Excellent customer service! Professional and very kind.
BD
Brett Davis
May 29, 2026
I’d recommend Jersey Mikes. I did a catering order for 23 orders, they gave me 21. The order wasn’t ready when I got there 30 min after my pick up time, which I did hoping by that time it would be ready, I started putting boxes in bags and carrying them to my car, no help. There were 5 people working and no other customers.
I asked if I could pick up a large catering order the following day at or slightly before their open time, they said no, I asked if I could talk to a manager they said the manager was busy, and I canceled my order for the next day. Jersey mikes did all of this, on time, no questions asked.
PL
Patricia De Lucca
May 9, 2026
Turkey Tom!!!! Absolutely my favorite sandwich ever!