JW
Jacob Woodruff
Aug 22, 2026
Its a beautiful location, but I'm unsure how it takes so long for them to warm up clearly frozen sysco products and then charge fresh prices for them. I'll be surprised if they make it another 4 months.
DO NOT EAT! The food was inedible. The service was very nice, but it was a 30 minute wait for our food, restaurant was not busy, and the food was disgusting. I don’t say that lightly. My husband ate one bite, and I at least tried the sides. Nothing was warm, let alone hot. Went to McDonalds instead.
They should change its name, they’re just using the previous restaurant’s name and reputation to attract costumers. The restaurant I visited this evening opened months ago, and it’s not related to the amazing to “Old Salem Tavern” restaurant.
Food was old, reheated, bad looking, disgusting. My friend returned her dish, it was impossible to eat. Do yourself a favor, don’t go to this restaurant ever, anything at home, even a bowl of corn flakes would be better than this.
RT
Robin Turner
Aug 12, 2026
Do not sleep on Old Salem Tavern. This was the BEST food I have ever had. The staff was amazing as well. I wish I had taken pictures of our food but I can’t say enough amazing things about the taste and portion size. We all took full to go boxes home because there was so much food left over. The cornbread melts in your mouth. James came out and talked with us and gave us a sample of each of their desserts. I don’t like apple pie but the apple pie cheesecake was like eating a little piece of heaven and the banana pudding cake made me sigh with delight. I can’t stress enough GO, GO, GO for your next meal out!
GM
Gloria Medlin
Aug 7, 2026
The wait time for someone to simply take our order was extremely long, then we waited nearly an hour to get our food. One of our orders was wrong, but we couldn’t dare send it back, we had already waited an hour to get it. Then when we asked for it to be taken off our bill it became quite an issue and the “manager “ told us she could not do that. Very poor customer service. Overall bad experience, Santina our second server was very nice, it was no fault of her
The customers at the next table also had to ask the status of their food, as they had arrived prior to us.
Too bad, I love Old Salem and had such high hopes.
The food was not good, and the prices were very high