Elizabeth's Pizza #1

Reviews

• FF

  Freeman

  1 day ago
  1.0
  Idk how this one has went down hill so bad. Maybe focus on food rather then social media. Salad was a very small portion and slimy, waterlogged lettuce. Uneatable! Would have been 3 fork fulls anyway... Pasta dry with an awful smell and taste. Went straight in the trash. Sub was a soaking wet mess and a sorry excuse for a Italian place. After they forgot to give me the measley salad I had to go back to get, not even a simple sorry for the inconvenience... Place was empty when I arrived and I know why now. The Westchester location is better if you're interested in even trying an Elizabeth pizza after this. 10/10 don't recommend
• BD

  Bobbie DiPilato

  Aug 12, 2026
  5.0
  We got the XL pizza and a side of meatballs delivered. Everything was fresh and delicious!
• KP

  Kiefer Perry

  Aug 10, 2026
  5.0
  This place is one of my absolute favorite restaurants and it has been since I was a little kid. My family and I absolutely love it here, the food has always been amazing, it doesn't matter what you order. Now for the employees. Some of the most kind people we've dealt with, over the years to today's group. The owners are always coming out to greet us and talk, they've always treated us like family, both AnnaLisa and her husband Luca. I cherish this place and the people here. My family and I will always support this place and it's owners. Please keep up the great work.
• VC

  Vic Clinco

  Jul 31, 2026
  5.0
  Saw that Elizabeth’s Pizza - Main Street Thomasville has been doing pasta in a parmesan reggiano cheese wheel, so we stopped in tonight and were so glad we did. This weeks variation had the pasta mixed with the parmesan cheese and a wonderful red sauce with pancetta and chicken, it was really good. Luca was amazing and not only walked us through what he was doing and talked about this dish, he talked to us about our wine choice. The meal was delicious, the service was spectacular and our overall experience was fantastic. It's a must try!!
• WS

  Wade Sullivan

  Jul 24, 2026
  5.0
  Luca made the Parmesan cheese wheel at our table tonight. We enjoyed watching him work his magic and it was absolutely fantastic!