Jimmy's Seafood Buffet

Reviews

• BB

  Bill

  6 days ago
  5.0
  We have been customers of Jimmys for the past 5 years. We had dinner there last night and as usual, the food and service were excellent. Our waiter was always checking on us. The buffet items were readily available and hot. Thank you again for another great visit to Jimmys.
• LW

  Lonnie White

  6 days ago
  5.0
  We live in Fayetteville and decided to try Jimmy’s on our annual OBX vacation. 16 of us went on Wild Wednesday to test out the hype about the crab legs. No one was disappointed. The selection of 11 different types of crab legs, lobster tails and claws, were great. Everything was cooked to perfection, the meat just slid out of the shells. The other foods on the buffet were seasoned and cooked well also. Jason our waiter, was very friendly and efficient and the manager was really nice as well. We traditionally go to Captain George’s when we come down; no knock on that establishment but I think we just started a new tradition.
• JL

  Jong Lee

  May 13, 2026
  4.0
  Dungeness and Snow crab were very good. I definitely got my money's worth. Those alone were worth the experience. Fried flounder was very good. We sat at the bar - Kirby the bartender was very nice and took care of us. Overall, the staff were very hard working. The sides had the overcooked cafeteria vibe. For example, the hush puppy's weren't soggy, but bland. Spare ribs - bland and overcooked. Steak - very tough, almost inedible. Lobster was dry and tough. Skipped dessert - but they didn't look too inviting. Bottom Line - I'd go back.
• BF

  Bonnie Farion

  May 5, 2026
  5.0
  Absolutely loved Jimmy’s. The seafood was excellent, I dined mostly on their crab, but also had lobster tails, clams and shrimp. Along with the Snow, Norwegian Red, and Dungeness, they had one I’ve never tried before, African Honey Crab, and it was divine!!! The service was excellent, the restaurant was spotless and perfectly designed for buffet and table service. Our waiter was friendly and attentive. I can’t wait to go back! My picture isn’t the best, I was too busy eating all the foods!
• TC

  tim c

  Apr 30, 2026
  1.0
  The first thing there was 6 of us and a 6 month old baby and they charged us gratuity for the baby that just laid there and slept. I told them I had bariatric surgery so I can't eat much all I ate was a hand full of shrimp and the charged me $85.00 thats ridiculous I think. And it wasn't that good there just money hungry. Not about the service just about what money they can make off you. I even showed them my card from the doctor where I had bariatric surgery they didnt care. But your sign says 7 or more people is automatic gratuity we just had 6 and a baby. If he would have told me or if I had known I would have ordered from menu. I was in there few years ago they didn't charge me full price. I literally just ate a few shrimp and cost me $85.00. You guys cold have done better plus I'm a senior not that that matters.

Frequently Asked Questions About Jimmy's Seafood Buffet