Peddler Steak House

Reviews

• LP

  Lisa Procacci

  3 days ago
  5.0
  I sat at the bar with Finn and Paisley! They were amazing, even with how busy it was they made sure everyone was happy with their meal! Best steak i have had in a while, overall great vibes! Final note, whoever is on salads.... 10/10 recommend a salad from here.
• DC

  David Cook

  6 days ago
  3.0
  This review makes me very sad to write. I grew up going to the Peddler for every special occasion and plenty of “why not” trips too. I have told everyone for years “if you want a great steak, go to the Peddler!” I retuned today after about a few years without visiting, and I was so very disappointed. My wife knew how much I had been wanting to go, so she splurged for Father’s Day. I had the 14oz Peddler Ribeye ordered medium rare. It was rare at most. Still a good cut of meat and lots of flavor. It was not seared at all and had little to no crust. My wife had the salmon and had no complaints. I tried a bite and it was delicious. The meat was sweet and tender, exactly what you want. My father in law ordered a New York strip, but was served prime rib. He didn’t tell anyone there was an issue and I didn’t realize until he was half way done. My son had the kids grilled shrimp, which were overcooked and rubbery. The biggest miss is the absence of the salad bar. You place a salad order on a piece of paper and it is built and delivered to you. There is an incredible variety of toppings, and if you are like me, you want almost all of them. What was delivered was maybe 5 leaves of greens with a mountain of uneven toppings spread far and wide. It was delicious, but the ratio of greens to toppings was unbalanced. The service was fine. Everyone was friendly, maybe even a touch overzealous. There was an employee that came by while we were eating salads and reached across the table and our plates to pick up a wrapper. The atmosphere has changed for certain. It used to have a vintage vibe where it was dark and moody with candles at each table. Now it looks like any other local grill in the southeast.
• MM

  Melene McMannen

  Jun 12, 2026
  5.0
  If you enjoy a Signature Ribeye or a Tenderloin Filet, drive to Boone NC and enjoy the absolute best!!! Salad rates too! Great, comfortable atmosphere! Love it!!!
• SH

  Steve Hatley

  Jun 7, 2026
  5.0
  I have been wanting to try this restaurant for years. The service was nice. Experience was phenomenal and the ribeye , baked potatoe, and rolls were indescribably sensational. One of the best steaks that I have ever eaten.
• WT

  Wally Turnbull

  Jun 1, 2026
  5.0
  A good steak. The Peddler Steak House is a small regional chain with good steaks. The “Peddler” comes to your table with assorted cuts of meat from which you choose your steak. Cute but not particularly useful except that he will cut it to your chosen thickness and charge you accordingly. The steaks are prime, the salad bar is generous, and the wine list includes some decent selections from local mountain producers with small vineyards. Nothing is fancy but everything is good. A 2 inch ribeye for two with big salads, baked potatoes, and a bottle from the Grandfather Winery make a perfect meal.