The Pickled Goat Bar & Grill

Reviews

• KH

  Kimberly Hardy

  2 days ago
  1.0
  This was our first time there and sadly may not be returning . For such a small place the atmosphere was nice BUT the waitress ignored us half the night (she was too busy with another table full of men), we had to flag her down several times to put in drink orders, our appetizers and food , she never came back to check on us once so needless to say we didn’t get to try the soft serve margaritas and that was the reason for even trying this place, the food was cold, we had to get another girl to bring us water because our waitress only brought 3 for 7 people and we had to tell her at the end how to fix our receipts. Not a good experience and sadly won’t be returning.
• AH

  Allen Hardy

  2 days ago
  2.0
  First time visit. Went here for their pop up Halloween. Service was absolutely horrible. Food would have probably been good but it was ice cold like it had been sitting a while before being brought out. Pizza cheese wasn’t even no longer melted. We were never asked if we wanted more drinks, which we did. Our bill for the table was $300 so it wasn’t like we weren’t spending money. It was super busy but they do this every season so they should have been prepared. Very disappointed.
• KK

  Kelly

  Sep 26, 2026
  5.0
  Great spot in New Baltimore! The perch basket was amazing —fresh, delicious, lightly breaded and surprisingly big pieces for a small fish. Pizza hit the spot too with a nice chewy and airy crust. There’s an arcade with a variety of games and pinball machines right there that makes it even better. Highly recommend stopping in!
• JJ

  Jess

  Sep 9, 2026
  5.0
  First time here, and I’m so glad I stopped in! Kristen and Rose were incredibly friendly, welcoming, and attentive. Kristen gave me some great recommendations, and everything I ordered came out absolutely perfect and delicious. I was also recommended the Aperol Spritz soft serve, and it was SO good! Not too sweet, super refreshing, and such a unique treat. I’ll definitely be coming back the next time I’m in town. Thank you, Kristen and Rose, for such a wonderful experience!
• SG

  Stephanie Goodrich-McPherson

  Sep 4, 2026
  2.0
  This is really disappointing to write because we used to love this place, but the service has gone so far downhill. This is now the SECOND time in just a couple of weeks that we’ve had an unbelievably long wait. Tonight, we were here for TWO HOURS before we even got our food. That’s not just a restaurant having an off night anymore. We’ve been coming here long enough to know that this is not how it used to be. The food and atmosphere made this a place we genuinely enjoyed, but the level of service lately makes it really hard to want to come back. I understand being busy. I understand being short-staffed. But two hours for food, twice within a matter of weeks, is just unacceptable. Something has clearly changed, and I really hope they figure it out because this used to be such a great local spot.