Food was absolutely awesome the waitress was 10 stars if you do t think u like Italian definitely try this place . My wife’s favorite place so took her there for her birthday glad we went there
It wasn't very busy when we got there yet it took 40 minutes to get out order served. I got the salmon, the salmon is overcooked and the potatoes were undercooked. The salads reminded me of salads from a cheap pizza place.
JD
Joshua Van Drese
Jul 28, 2026
I was there this evening. Food took 45 minutes or so to come out, all except for one. That took another 20 minutes to come out. When it got to the table, the lasagna looked completely different than the other one at our table already. The outside was scorching hot, but the inside was cold like it was just out of the fridge (because it was). Took them 25 minutes to bring another piece out which was the same, full of grease standing on the top from the re heat. Everyone else was done eating so they just boxed it up. Paid full price, zero care from the place. We go here weekly but we will never be back. Re-heating cold leftover food and serving it as fresh is gross.
NM
Noah Morrish
Jul 20, 2026
Came to eat with a table of 4, the two orders of ribs my table ordered were dry and cold, like they had sat for 2 hours. The fettuccine Alfredo was also cold, as well as the sides of broccoli. The roasted potatoes were hard and undercooked beyond belief. The only single piece of hot food that touched the table was lasagna my partner ordered. Not a single person finished their food, the waitress only checked on my table one time about 20 minutes after we got the food. I didn’t get a single refill on my water after finishing it maybe 5 minutes after receiving it. I will never return and I urge anyone reading this to not eat here. The cooks obviously do not care about what they are putting out, nor do the servers care about what they are serving.
My husband and I were on the road and found this restaurant. We were so glad we did! It was clean, the staff was pleasant and the prices, fair. We loved every bite, from bread to salad to mastaccioli and seafood pasta. The only downside was the music, 50s pop, that we didn't care for, but it wouldn't keep us away.
We're keeping it in mind for future trips.
Excellent job, Italia Gardens!