Maple Lawn Pizza & Sub

Reviews

• NE

  Nicole Eastman

  2 days ago
  5.0
  I couldn’t figure out what I wanted to eat this afternoon, so wandered into Maple Lawn Pizza and Subs. The kid working behind the counter was so nice and so helpful. He asked me what I was in the mood for, what I liked, trying to help me decide. I ultimately didn’t stay only because I really didn’t know what I was in the mood for. However, I would go back for the customer service alone! I wish I had gotten his name, but it was a younger, probably high school boy, and so soft-spoken - working today, 10/13 at 330ish. To whom ever you are, thank you for being so sweet!
• TG

  Tedd Gardiner

  5 days ago
  4.0
  Have only tried the pizza, but the Butter Chicken is very tasty. Wait times were pretty long early on, but they seem to have their system down now. All in all a great addition to the Maple Lawn dining scene.
• CF

  Carol Anne Frezza

  Sep 20, 2026
  5.0
  We ordered pizza for pickup on a friday night - it was hot and ready for us to pick up at the set time. The order was correct including the additional toppings we had asked for and honestly we thought it was delicious. We'd much rather support a local business than a large pizza chain so this will be our go to pizza place from now on. Overall pizza was hot, delicious, and made in a timely manner. Plus its right next to Bruster's so we got a pint of ice cream to make Friday night perfect!
• RH

  Rachel Hoffberger

  Sep 19, 2026
  1.0
  If I could give zero stars for service I would. Food is terrible. Everything seems like it's reheated pre-made frozen stuff. Pretty sure my cheeseburger was from Costco. At least that's what it tasted like. There was ONE person working front of house, and she was sitting down looking at her phone when we walked in. She never greeted us and never thanked us when we left. (The place was pretty empty on a Saturday night.) My son loves Lemonade, and I saw what looked like Lemonade in the self-serve drink cooler. I asked the girl if that was lemonade and she said yes. She didn't mention that it was strawberry dragonfruit lemonade. My son took one sip and hated it, couldn't drink the rest. I took one sip. It tasted like pool saltwater with a dash of lemon. While we ate, a customer came in wanting to buy a bottle of water. The girl was nowhere to be found. This patient woman waited for several minutes until the girl eventually came back into the room with her purse over her shoulder, staring at her phone again. Had she just taken a break? We will not be back. I can't believe this place has so many good reviews.
• GC

  Gregory Cooper

  Sep 18, 2026
  1.0
  We were excited when they opened and wanted to support a new local business. The food is pretty good. But we have now ordered from there almost ten times and every single time they have gotten the order wrong. The first several times we thought they were just working out the bugs. The next time we talked to the owner to let her know. It happened again. We waited a while then ordered again. It doesn't matter if you call in the order or place it online. It's really incredible that they get the order wrong every time. Even if the food is well made getting something you specifically didn't want runs the meal.