twenty-eight Atlantic

Reviews

• MC

  Michael C

  Sep 1, 2026
  5.0
  The courses are amazing and on another level. The location and atmosphere are beautiful. We went for our anniversary and had a wonderful time. Thank you!
• HI

  HC I

  Aug 18, 2026
  1.0
  My family and I dined here last week. The atmosphere was beautiful and our waiter was lovely. The timing between courses was too long and too much of a production for our liking, but we could have overlooked that had my daughter and I not gotten sick from the fish course. Most of the food was okay but definitely not 5 star. I knew the fish did not taste good to me but I was so hungry I regrettably kept eating it. My daughter and I were the only two at the table to have the fish and we both were sick a couple of hours after returning home. My daughter felt better the next day but I did not (I'll spare you the details), and it was recommended that I take antibiotics when, 3 days later, I was still sick. I emailed the restaurant the day after our dinner to make them aware of this, and it has been 1 week and still no response. You would think that if they did not feel an apology was warranted, at the very least they would want to find out more to alert the chef so that more people did not get sick. This happened to me 25 yrs ago at one of our favorite Auberge resorts and the chef personally called to find out how I was and kept checking on me days later. Because of the way they handled the situation, we did not think twice about returning to the resort and have many times since. As I've come to find - surprisingly this kind of thing seems to be unavoidable occasionally with seafood - even with top tier dining. What IS under a restaurant's control however, is how they treat their customer when they are responsible for sickening you, which in my case has been unacceptable. I just read another review here from 6 days ago from a diner who also got sick which was the day after we were there. Something is not right here and I will let the health dept know since the restaurant clearly does not care it is making people sick. There are many other places to eat on the Cape that have settings just as or more beautiful, with better food. I truly question how they earned their 5 stars - it must be an old rating.
• RH

  Russ Hamilton

  Aug 16, 2026
  5.0
  Top 5 meal ever, amazing meals. Does not come cheap but we were celebrating sister's 80th and wife's 70th! Everything was delusions and unique. Service awesome, entire modern Dining area faces bay, excellent bar has dark English pub feel. Wedding going on outside that looked awesome!
• JP

  Jay P

  Aug 12, 2026
  1.0
  Its hard to believe the restaurant has an overall rating is 4.5. The only good thing about this place are the views- and the good truly ends there. First of all we were sick all night after eating. When I reached out to the manager and left a voicemail (3 times), I didn't receive any return calls. I specified that there was an issue, so apparently they don't want to hear it or care enough to even try to address it. The noise from the music in the next room was as inconsiderate as it gets, and it was still dinner hours. I couldn't even have a conversation with my wife. The service was terrible and the food matched the service! Read the negative reviews and I think you'll see a pattern.
• EO

  Eric Olsen

  Aug 11, 2026
  5.0
  Outstanding! Upscale restaurant with an outstanding menu, great ambiance and a great drink menu! The house feel is separated into a beautiful dining room with wide open views of the bay and a very nice bar with it's own dark atmosphere. The between course sorbets were excellent and we loved the gazpacho and the peking duck! The Cambridge cream dessert was delicious.