Indigo Martha’s

Reviews

• SR

  Smita Rangesh

  1 day ago
  5.0
  We had a wonderful lunch here. Being summer, the outdoor patio was perfect. Staff was friendly and courteous. The food and drinks were the highlight. We were an all vegetarian party of 11 and everything we ordered was flavourful. The only teeny negative was that the breads did not arrive on time with the main entrees, so a few of us had to wait. We would go back in a heartbeat.
• JL

  Jan Lange

  3 days ago
  5.0
  This was a fantastic choice. The food was amazing, so was the service. Our server (Valentine) was extremely attentive and very helpful and informative with the food. My whole family had a great experience, everyone loved their dishes. Personally I had tikka masala (heavenly) chicken, with a light fluffy butter naan and some mango lassi that had a perfect sweet sour balance and saffron garnish. I can definitely say this is probably one of the best Indian restaurants I've ever been to. They also have just enough options to satisfy folks that don't like Indian food. The atmosphere is upscale, and it's clear the management focuses on small details, even down to immaculate bathrooms.
• ZI

  Ziiakhidin Ismanzhonov

  Aug 6, 2026
  1.0
  Absolutely unacceptable. This was by far one of the worst delivery experiences I’ve ever had. The wait time was ridiculous, and there was little to no communication about the delay. If you can’t handle the number of orders you’re receiving, stop accepting them or at least be honest with your customers. People order delivery because they expect it within a reasonable time, not after an endless wait. My food arrived so late that the entire experience was ruined. This level of service shows complete disrespect for your customers’ time. I will never order from this restaurant again, and I strongly discourage anyone else from doing so unless you enjoy wasting your time waiting for food that should have arrived long ago.
• BC

  Brian Carroll

  Aug 2, 2026
  2.0
  I had a really disappointing experience at Indigo in Edgartown on Martha’s Vineyard. My tab came out to $45, and I paid using Apple Pay. I made sure to leave a 20% tip, which I thought was fair for the service I received. However, after checking my card statement later, I was shocked to see that I had been charged $100. It felt extremely shady, and the only explanation I can think of is that the bartender took the payment machine and added an extra tip without my consent.
• MG

  M Giordano

  Jul 27, 2026
  5.0
  You may not always think about Indian food while on a beach vacation but if you find yourself on the Vineyard and are looking for a fun night out Indigo is your place. The food is authentic and delicious. They atmosphere is sophisticated and elegant with a beachy relaxed feel. We ate outside on the lovely deck which has a beautiful outdoor bar. The cocktails are creative and delicious. The waitstaff is attentive and happy to answer questions about the menu. We were a group of 7 and shared everything. One of my daughters has celiac and our server was able to help her navigate the menu. We were lucky enough to be there for their trivia night which is hosted every Thursday night. the space is fun and energetic, there is plenty of parking and the indoor space is super chic. If you love Indian food you will not be disappointed and if someone in your party isn't feeling it with the Indian, cuisine, don't sweat it because there are several other options to accommodate your taste. We can't wait to go back!