Indigo Martha’s

Reviews

• MB

  Maria Bounas

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Great Indian restaurant on the island! The food was so good and the staff were very friendly and attentive. We ordered our meals at the mild spice level just to get an idea of the house spice level, but next time we will go to medium. We loved the samosa chaat, saag paneer, and lamb tikka masala. Lots of vegetarian options and they even have burgers and sandwiches so something for everyone! They also have a great bar with TVs if you’re looking to catch a game.
• TD

  Terry Duncan

  5 days ago
  5.0
  First time going here and trying Butter Chicken and it was excellent. Food was prepared as ordered and arrived in a timely manor. They adjusted spice level perfectly. Owner and wait staff were friendly and accommodating. We were pleasantly surprised that Wednesdays are Karaoke night. Really fun time. Definitely would recommend it.
• GC

  Gregory Charlop

  Jun 22, 2026
  4.0
  Delicious food but overpriced. Indigo is a wonderful Indian restaurant in Edgartown. The service was fast and efficient, and they have plenty of indoor and outdoor seating, including two bars. I really enjoyed my chana masala with garlic naan, but $50 seemed a bit steep, even for Martha's Vineyard. I'd definitely come back, but their prices make this more of a special treat than an everyday meal.
• SW

  sophia walker

  Jun 21, 2026
  5.0
  This was my boyfriend and I’s second time here and we could not recommend it more! I have gluten and dairy allergies and he has nut allergies which makes dining out a bit complicated, but the staff was very knowledgeable and careful and there were plenty of menu options that we could share (bonus points for labeled allergens on the menu)! Drinks were unique and phenomenal, salads/apps were light and delicious, and the entrees were incredible. They let you customize the spice level, so I got spicy and my boyfriend got mild. The spicy definitely had a good kick to it, but was still very flavorful. The mild was delicious as well, they do not skimp out on seasoning over here. Gorgeous outdoor seating options too! Definitely recommend trying them out, you won’t regret it!
• CD

  Catherine Dorian

  Jun 16, 2026
  5.0
  We were a spontaneous party of twelve, and Indigo was able to accommodate us without advanced notice. The food is delectable. I follow a plant-based diet, so I was particularly grateful that they label their vegan dishes. The staff were attentive, friendly, and, knowing that we each had coupons for our meals, they split the check in such a way that allowed us all the best discount. The owner is also super cool. Cannot recommend this place enough!