Magnolia Bakery

Reviews

• GP

  Gale Pearce

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Going to Magnolia is a great way to celebrate any event. And they also did a great job fulfilling an order for 25 guests!! Everything I have tried has been fabulous! And Kathleen made the experience even more enjoyable!
• BP

  Betsy Pfeiffer

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Magnolia Bakery is absolutely exceptional! From the moment you walk in, everything feels welcoming, charming, and special. The baked goods are incredible, beautifully presented, and every bit as delicious as you would hope. The banana pudding is like nothing you have experienced and you can even tailor it to your taste bud with add ons but it is not necessary because on its own it is to die for. The attention to detail, quality, and overall experience truly set this place apart from other bakeries in town. Everything feels thoughtfully done, and it’s clear how much care goes into what they create. It was fresh! An absolute must-visit, and a place I would recommend to anyone from age two to ninety two!
• AH

  Amy Harty

  3 days ago
  5.0
  If you have not been to Magnolia Bakery yet then you are missing out! Not only does it have the most mouth watering desserts but the service is super friendly! The bakery is a total vibe and we can’t wait to go back.
• NW

  Nevaeh Winstead

  Sep 27, 2026
  3.0
  The cake was decent, but honestly, it was pretty dry and didn’t feel worth the $80+ price. I’ve had better cakes from a box mix. This was for my sister’s birthday, and we never received a confirmation that the cake was ready. We tried calling but couldn’t get an answer, so we ended up going in person to make sure the cake would be ready for the celebration. When we arrived, they couldn’t find our order in the system because our email had been written down incorrectly with an extra “h” in the Yahoo address. Overall, I’m glad we were able to get the cake for the celebration, but unfortunately, the quality and the communication were disappointing, especially considering the price.
• CC

  Chassity Cunningham

  Sep 27, 2026
  2.0
  Very disappointed in the items we tried and felt it was way overpriced for what it was. The classic banana pudding was fine and happened to be the best item we got. It wasn’t spectacular but wasn’t bad. We also bought three slices of cake. They were so beautiful and we were so excited to try them but the cake was so bad. All three were very dry and the flavor just wasn’t great. The icing was not good. The cake was so dense. Of the three slices, the red velvet was probably the best only because its flavor was slightly better than the other two slices but it still left something to be desired as well. The salted caramel cookie was way too salty. Had it been just chocolate chip though, it would have been really good. Based on our spend and what we got yesterday I would have rated it a 1 but because we didn’t get to try the cheesecakes or icebox bars and the pudding wasn’t terrible, we give it a 2, but we won’t go back. It’s so pricey to be so lackluster.