Pony Express Pizza

Reviews

• LV

  Lettie Viars

  5 days ago
  1.0
  After I've considered writing this review tonight left be no choice you can't say you're calling somebody when your iPhone is connected to your iWatch and it says calling the entire time I've always got my pizza don't cut don't cut my pizza I can cut it when I get home and it will stay fresh. Never been a big deal until tonight why all of a sudden? Cuz I was too lazy to follow simple instructions. Every time I call a pizza place I asked them not to cut my pizza never problem. Simple instructions go a long ways but changing ingredients pony Express Pizza will never be the same in my eyes Stromboli's are greasy and nasty. Pizzas are supposed to be made the way you want them. Worse Pizza ever. Won't go back. Advertising family combo for $31.50 and then upcharge to $38.70???? I paid for this order I should have got my pizza the way I wanted it made. Wasn't done all the way pizza was slightly doughy. Was undercooked , and hand tossed was a bit overcooked,crust was tough and bit burnt. Breadsticks was overcooked. Caused our stomachs to be upset with Pain. Would NOT Recommend this place to anyone.
• RR

  Rikki

  Aug 28, 2026
  1.0
  Undercook thin crust and burnt hand tossed pizza couldn’t eat so I send it back and asked for a refund was told no bc nothing was wrong with the pizzas I don’t complain about my pizza unless it is something I can’t eat bc I love pizza I pacifically love there taco pizza was Extremely disappointed that I paid 40 something and couldn’t enjoy it Manager was extremely rude and they had both the pizzas with the total of maybe five slices missing out of both of the pizza bc Of course, multiple people were going to eat the pizza. We’re not be back very disappointed if I could give zero stars I would. Manager’s name was Carol I think
• TL

  Talynn Lewis

  Jul 9, 2026
  5.0
  Thank you Andy for always taking care of us! Your pizza and wings are our favorite around!!
• NS

  NOT Shawn

  May 29, 2026
  1.0
  I'm very unhappy. The quality of pizza hasn't changed but the price sure has. Not long ago these pizzas were about $20 and you got a second one for free. Now they are almost $30 for the same deal making it not a deal at all. This was the main reason we came here. As a middle class family of five every dollar counts, unfortunately we will just save up our points and go with dominoes. At least their deals are actually deals.
• PW

  Preston Wilson

  May 13, 2026
  5.0
  Best Pizza in Henderson for as long as i can remember