Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• NK

  Nathan Kaiser

  Jun 8, 2026
  3.0
  With all the big families in SM, they do a good job keeping up. Pizza is average, not bad for the price
• MM

  Michelle

  Jun 5, 2026
  1.0
  I don't know what has happened to this place. They seem to have no clue what they're doing or how to actually treat the customer. Yesterday after 2 hours, they still hadn't even started to make my pizza and had no idea when my order would even be ready. They were about 40 pizzas behind. We ended up canceling our order and I'm guessing quite a few other customers did the same. Every pizza we order is wrong. Is it really that hard to put the right toppings on a pizza? They recently remodeled the store, which is nice. They need to remodel the staff.
• TL

  Travis LaPierre

  Apr 18, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered a med meats pizza ahead of time 20 min ahead. Pizza wasn't ready , I waited another five minutes , still no pizza. I was the only customer the pizza rack was empty. I canceled my order, called to complain and a cop showed up today to tell me I'm banned for a year to this location. Over Pizza one pizza.
• CS

  Crunchy Stingray

  Feb 16, 2026
  2.0
  I've been to this place dozens of times ever since it opened. I think after all this time it is time to leave an honest review. When I first started going here everything was amazing. The food and service was outstanding. But as time went on I noticed their quality started going downhill. Now every time I order recently either the pizza is overcooked, the crust is too thick, or the cut is imperfect. There is also a wait time after you arrive because the employees are goofing around in the kitchen. I've never had an issue with the employees. They are all friendly and understanding. But I was standing around waiting almost 10 minutes for my online order. I went to pick up 40 minutes after ordering online. It has happened a few times before recently. Also with my recent order my sauce container was breached almost as if they slammed it on the box. The brownie I ordered was unevenly cut and my pizza was overcooked. Seriously the manager need to bring up their quality control and teach their workers how to properly present the food. Papa John's in Wamego does a better job. Saint Marys used to have better service than Wamego. If they can bring up their quality control I will give them higher stars.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza