$5.99 Sandwich Deal (The Pepe®)
$5.99
HAM, PROVOLONE, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Brand Certified
Jimmy John's
3.6(268 reviews)
Certified by Jimmy John's • Aug 30, 2026
Business Details
2400 Marketplace Blvd, Shelbyville, IN
46176, United States
Certified by Jimmy John's • Aug 30, 2026
(317) 604-5072
Certified by Jimmy John's • Aug 30, 2026
https://locations.jimmyjohns.com/in/shelbyville/sandwiches-3008.html
Certified by Jimmy John's • Aug 30, 2026
About
Certified by Jimmy John's • Aug 30, 2026
Sandwich Restaurant
Sandwiches made with hand-sliced meats, fresh veggies and bread that's never more than 4 hours old. Freaky Fast® makes it Freaky Fresh.® Order online for delivery or pick up.
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Accepts reservationsNot available
- Requires reservationsNot available
Location
Certified by Jimmy John's • Aug 30, 2026
Hours
Certified by Jimmy John's • Aug 30, 2026
Monday11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Tuesday11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Thursday11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Saturday11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Sunday11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Menu
1 menu · 187 items
Explore offerings from Jimmy John's on 2400 Marketplace Blvd in Shelbyville, with popular $5.99 sandwich deal, what’s new, toasted sandwiches, and wraps available at this location.
Menu
187 items
$5.99 Sandwich Deal
For a limited time, get a Turkey Tom®, The Pepe®, Vito®, or The Veggie for $5.99
$5.99 Sandwich Deal (Turkey Tom®)
$5.99
TURKEY, lettuce, tomato & mayo
$5.99 Sandwich Deal (Vito®)
$5.99
SALAMI, CAPOCOLLO, PROVOLONE, onion, lettuce, tomato, oil & vinegar, & oregano-basil
$5.99 Sandwich Deal (The Veggie)
$5.99
PROVOLONE, AVOCADO SPREAD, cucumber, lettuce, tomato & mayo (Shown with Jimmy Peppers®)
What’s New
Fresh additions and limited-time favorites. Check out the latest sandwiches, wraps, sides, and more
PB&J Cookie
$1.79
Peanut butter meets sweet grape filling in a soft-baked cookie that tastes like your favorite childhood sandwich—reimagined.
Buffalo Ranch Chicken Wrap
ALL-NATURAL CHICKEN, Buffalo Wild Wings® Medium Buffalo Sauce, Homestyle Ranch, Crispy Carrot Noodles, Sliced Celery, Onion, Tomato, Lettuce, all on a Flour Tortilla
Buffalo Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
Crispy Jimmy Chips® coated in bold Buffalo seasoning for the perfect balance of heat, crunch, and flavor in every bite
CLASSIC LEMONADE
$2.39 - $2.49
Classic lemonade, made with real fruit and cane sugar
Strawberry Lemonade
$2.39 - $2.49
Strawberry lemonade, made with real fruit and cane sugar
Toasted Sandwiches
Try one of our new toasted sandwiches in a variety of mouth-watering flavors. Melty cheese…need we say more?
Ham & Three Cheese Melt
DOUBLE HAM, CHEDDAR CHEESE, PARMESAN CHEESE, PROVOLONE CHEESE & mayo
Chicken Bacon Ranch
ALL-NATURAL CHICKEN, BACON & PROVOLONE, ranch, lettuce, tomato, onion & mayo
Ultimate Italian
CAPOCOLLO, SALAMI, HAM, BACON, PARMESAN & PROVOLONE, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, oregano-basil & oil & vinegar
Roast Beef & Cheddar
ROAST BEEF & CHEDDAR CHEESE, horseradish sauce, crispy fried onions, lettuce, tomato, onion & mayo
#7 Spicy East Coast Italian (Toasted)
DOUBLE SALAMI, DOUBLE CAPOCOLLO & PROVOLONE, Jimmy Peppers®, oil & vinegar, onion, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#8 Billy Club® (Toasted)
ROAST BEEF, HAM & PROVOLONE, yellow mustard, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#9 Italian Night Club® (Toasted)
SALAMI, CAPOCOLLO, HAM, PROVOLONE, onion, lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil & vinegar, & oregano-basil
#10 Hunter's Club® (Toasted)
DOUBLE ROAST BEEF & PROVOLONE, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#11 Country Club® (Toasted)
TURKEY, HAM, PROVOLONE, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#12 Beach Club® (Toasted)
TURKEY, PROVOLONE, AVOCADO SPREAD, cucumber, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#13 Jimmy Cubano® (Toasted)
BACON, HAM & PROVOLONE, pickle, mayo & yellow mustard
#14 Bootlegger Club® (Toasted)
ROAST BEEF, TURKEY, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#15 Club Tuna® (Toasted)
TUNA SALAD, PROVOLONE, cucumber, lettuce & tomato
#16 Club Lulu® (Toasted)
TURKEY, BACON, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#17 Ultimate Porker® (Toasted)
HAM, BACON, lettuce, tomato & mayo
J.J.B.L.T.® (Toasted)
BACON, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Wraps
Wraps are now available year-round in three delicious flavors!
Buffalo Ranch Chicken Wrap
ALL-NATURAL CHICKEN, Buffalo Wild Wings® Medium Buffalo Sauce, Homestyle Ranch, Crispy Carrot Noodles, Sliced Celery, Onion, Tomato, Lettuce, all on a Flour Tortilla
Kickin’ Ranch® Chicken Wrap
CHICKEN & PROVOLONE, Kickin’ Ranch®, Jimmy Peppers®, onion, lettuce, tomato, mayo, & flour wrap
Chicken Caesar Wrap
CHICKEN, PARMESAN, Caesar dressing, mini croutons, lettuce, tomato, mayo, garlic & herb wrap
Tuscan Italian Wrap
SALAMI, CAPOCOLLO, HAM, PARMESAN, lettuce, onion, tomato, mayo, oil & vinegar, oregano-basil & garlic & herb wrap
Favorites
Specialty sandwiches for those who want to kick things up a notch
#7 Spicy East Coast Italian
DOUBLE SALAMI, DOUBLE CAPOCOLLO & PROVOLONE, Jimmy Peppers®, oil & vinegar, onion, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#8 Billy Club®
ROAST BEEF, HAM & PROVOLONE, yellow mustard, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#9 Italian Night Club®
SALAMI, CAPOCOLLO, HAM, PROVOLONE, onion, lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil & vinegar, & oregano-basil
#10 Hunter's Club®
DOUBLE ROAST BEEF & PROVOLONE, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#11 Country Club®
TURKEY, HAM, PROVOLONE, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#12 Beach Club®
TURKEY, PROVOLONE, AVOCADO SPREAD, cucumber, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#13 Jimmy Cubano®
BACON, HAM & PROVOLONE, pickle, mayo & yellow mustard
#14 Bootlegger Club®
ROAST BEEF, TURKEY, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#15 Club Tuna®
TUNA SALAD, PROVOLONE, cucumber, lettuce & tomato
#16 Club Lulu®
TURKEY, BACON, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#17 Ultimate Porker®
HAM, BACON, lettuce, tomato & mayo
J.J.B.L.T.®
BACON, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Originals
Classic sandwiches done right, made with fresh ingredients just the way you like
#1 The Pepe®
HAM, PROVOLONE, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#2 Big John®
ROAST BEEF, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#3 Totally Tuna®
TUNA SALAD, cucumber, lettuce & tomato
#4 Turkey Tom®
TURKEY, lettuce, tomato & mayo
#5 Vito®
SALAMI, CAPOCOLLO, PROVOLONE, onion, lettuce, tomato, oil & vinegar, & oregano-basil
#6 The Veggie
PROVOLONE, AVOCADO SPREAD, cucumber, lettuce, tomato & mayo (Shown with Jimmy Peppers®)
Combos
Any sandwich or wrap paired with your choice of a side and drink
Buffalo Ranch Chicken Wrap Combo
$0.10 - $12.55
A Buffalo Ranch Chicken Wrap with your choice of a side and a drink
Toasted Sandwich Combo
$12.89
Your choice of our all new toasted sandwiches with your choice of a side and a drink.
Wrap Combo
$12.55
A Wrap with your choice of a side and a drink
Favorite Combo
$11.55
Any Favorite sandwich with your choice of a side and a drink
Original Combo
$10.15
Any Original sandwich with your choice of a side and a drink
Little John Combo
$6.49
Any Little John sandwich with your choice of a side and a drink
J.J. Gargantuan® Combo
$13.09
A J.J. Gargantuan sandwich with your choice of a side and a drink
Slim Combo
$8.29
Any Slim sandwich with your choice of a side and a drink
Giant Toasted Sandwich Combo
$21.99
Your choice of our all new toasted sandwiches with your choice of a side and a drink.
Giant Favorite Combo
$19.59
Any Giant Favorite sandwich with your choice of a side and a drink
Giant Original Combo
$17.49
Any Giant Original sandwich with your choice of a side and a drink
Giant J.J. Gargantuan® Combo
$22.59
A Giant J.J. Gargantuan sandwich with your choice of a side and a drink
Giant Slim Combo
$12.99
Any Giant Slim sandwich with your choice of a side and a drink
Chicken
Craving chicken? We’ve got you covered.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
CHICKEN, PARMESAN, Caesar dressing, mini croutons, lettuce, tomato, mayo, garlic & herb wrap
Kickin’ Ranch® Chicken Wrap
CHICKEN & PROVOLONE, Kickin’ Ranch®, Jimmy Peppers®, onion, lettuce, tomato, mayo, & flour wrap
Chicken Bacon Ranch
ALL-NATURAL CHICKEN, BACON & PROVOLONE, ranch, lettuce, tomato, onion & mayo
Little Johns
A mini version of any Original sandwich. Perfect for smaller appetites.
Little John #1
HAM, PROVOLONE, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Little John #2
ROAST BEEF, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Little John #3
TUNA SALAD, cucumber, lettuce & tomato
Little John #4
TURKEY, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Little John #5
SALAMI, CAPOCOLLO, PROVOLONE, onion, lettuce, tomato, oil & vinegar, & oregano-basil
Little John #6
PROVOLONE, AVOCADO SPREAD, cucumber, lettuce, tomato & mayo
Gargantuan
Five proteins and provolone served on 8" or 16" French, sliced wheat or Unwich®. Huge enough to feed the hungriest of humans!
The J.J. Gargantuan®
SALAMI, CAPOCOLLO, TURKEY, ROAST BEEF, HAM, PROVOLONE, onion, lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil & vinegar, & oregano-basil
Plain Slims®
Single protein and/or provolone served on 8" or 16" French, sliced wheat or Unwich®. Perfect for kids!
Slim 1
HAM & PROVOLONE
Slim 2
ROAST BEEF
Slim 3
TUNA SALAD
Slim 4
TURKEY
Slim 5
SALAMI, CAPOCOLLO & PROVOLONE
Slim 6
PROVOLONE
Desserts
Satisfy your sweet tooth with one of our cookies or brownie
PB&J Cookie
$1.79
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.99
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
$1.99
Fudge Chocolate Brownie
$1.79
Sides
Add your favorite chips, pasta salad, or Jimmy Pickle
Buffalo Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
A crisp, refreshing mix of cucumbers, tzatziki, sliced pickles and onions for bright Greek flavor in every bite
BBQ Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
Jalapeño Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
Regular Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
Salt & Vinegar Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
Homestyle Potato Salad
$2.69
Pesto Bowtie Pasta Salad
$2.29
Bow tie pasta with creamy pesto dressing and sundried tomatoes.
Pickle (Whole)
$1.69
Pickle (Halved)
$1.69
Pickle (Quartered)
$1.69
Cucumbers (Sliced)
$0.49
French Bread
$2.00
Our Freaky Fresh® 16” French bread is perfectly golden and baked all day long. Quantity limitations and participation may vary by store.
Avocado Spread (Side Portion)
$1.39
Kickin' Ranch® (Small)
$0.49
Kickin’ Ranch® (Large)
$2.29
Creamy and cool ranch, with a kick of heat
Homestyle Ranch (Small)
$0.49
Homestyle Ranch (Small)
Homestyle Ranch (Large)
$2.29
Drinks
Choose from an assortment of fountain or bottle drinks
Regular Classic Lemonade
$2.49
Large Classic Lemonade
$2.39
Regular Strawberry Lemonade
$2.49
Large Strawberry Lemonade
$2.39
Bottled Water
$1.59
20oz Bottle Coke®
$2.59
Large Fountain Coke®
$2.39
Regular Fountain Coke®
$2.49
20oz Bottle Diet Coke®
$2.59
Large Fountain Diet Coke®
$2.39
Regular Fountain Diet Coke®
$2.49
Regular Fountain Dr Pepper®
$2.49
Large Fountain Dr Pepper®
$2.39
20oz Bottle Sprite®
$2.59
Large Fountain Sprite®
$2.39
Regular Fountain Sprite®
$2.49
Large Fountain Iced Tea - Unsweet
$2.39
Regular Fountain Iced Tea - Unsweet
$2.49
Large Fountain Iced Tea - Sweet
$2.39
Regular Fountain Iced Tea - Sweet
$2.49
Large Fountain Cherry Coke®
$2.39
Regular Fountain Cherry Coke®
$2.49
Large Fountain Root Beer
$2.39
Regular Fountain Root Beer
$2.49
Large Fountain Powerade® - Mountain Blast
$2.39
Regular Fountain Powerade® - Mountain Blast
$2.49
Large Fountain Hi-C® - Fruit Punch
$2.39
Regular Fountain Hi-C® - Fruit Punch
$2.49
Catering Bundles
Create the catering bundle of your dreams and get your favorite sandwiches, wraps, or both! Customize your sides, add desserts, and you’ve got yourself a perfect spread.
Small Catering Bundle
$66.99
Perfect for your next group occasion. This bundle feeds 6 to 10 and includes: 1 box of 18 third sandwiches, 6-pack individual premium sides, 6 chips, and 6 desserts.
Large Catering Bundle
$179.99
Perfect for your next group occasion. This bundle feeds 15 to 20 and includes: 1 box of 30 third sandwiches, 1 12-piece half wraps box, 2 6-pack individual premium sides, 15 chips and 15 desserts.
Chips Bundle
$8.49
Perfect for your next group occasion! This bundle includes a variety of 6 chips.
Desserts Bundle
$9.59
Perfect for your next group occasion! This bundle includes a variety of 6 desserts.
Bottle Drink Bundle
$8.99
Perfect for your next group occasion! This bundle includes a variety of 4 bottle drinks.
Party Boxes
Turn any gathering into a party with a box of delicious sandwiches or wraps. Choose from 12, 18, or 30-piece options.
18-Piece
$39.59
Box of 18 third sandwiches. Your choice of any of our sandwiches. Some sandwiches cost a little more than others.
30-Piece
$72.99
Box of 30 third sandwiches. Your choice of any of our sandwiches. Some sandwiches cost a little more than others.
12 Half Sandwiches
$38.59
Box of 12 half sandwiches. Your choice of any of our sandwiches. Some sandwiches cost a little more than others.
12 Half Wraps
$56.99
Box of 12 half wraps. Your choice of any of our wraps.
Box Lunches
Cover all your food bases with our box lunches. Comes with your choice of any regular sandwich or wrap, plus your choice of side, dessert, and pickle. What more could you need?
Box Lunches
$0.60 - $12.89
Box of your choice of sandwich or wrap plus a bag of chips, dessert & pickle spear. Some sandwiches cost a little more than others.
Lil' Lunches
$5.39
Box of your choice of a Little John & a bag of chips.
Desserts
Satisfy your sweet tooth with one of our cookies or brownie.
PB&J Cookie
$1.79
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.99
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
$1.99
Variety Cookie
$1.99
Fudge Chocolate Brownie
$1.79
Brownie made with semi-sweet chocolate, cocoa and melted chocolate.
Sides
Add on chips, pickles, or new premium sides to your catering order.
Buffalo Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
A crisp, refreshing mix of cucumbers, tzatziki, sliced pickles and onions for bright Greek flavor in every bite
Pesto Bowtie Pasta Salad (Individual)
$2.29
Bow tie pasta with creamy pesto dressing and sundried tomatoes.
Homestyle Potato Salad (Individual)
$2.69
Regular Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
BBQ Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
Jalapeño Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
Salt & Vinegar Jimmy Chips®
$1.89
Pickle (Whole)
$1.69
Pickle (Halved)
$1.69
Pickle (Quartered)
$1.69
Pickle Bucket
$6.99
Cucumbers (Sliced)
$0.49
French Bread
$2.00
Our Freaky Fresh® 16” French bread is perfectly golden and baked all day long. Quantity limitations and participation may vary by store.
Avocado Spread (Side Portion)
$1.39
Kickin' Ranch® (Small)
$0.49
Kickin’ Ranch® (Large)
$2.29
Creamy and cool ranch, with a kick of heat
Homestyle Ranch (Small)
$0.49
Homestyle Ranch (Small)
Homestyle Ranch (Large)
$2.29
Drinks
Choose from an assortment of fountain or bottle drinks.
Bottled Water
$1.59
20oz Bottle Coke®
$2.59
Large Fountain Coke®
$2.39
Regular Fountain Coke®
$2.49
20oz Bottle Diet Coke®
$2.59
Large Fountain Diet Coke®
$2.39
Regular Fountain Diet Coke®
$2.49
20oz Bottle Sprite®
$2.59
Large Fountain Dr Pepper®
$2.39
Regular Fountain Dr Pepper®
$2.49
Large Fountain Sprite®
$2.39
Regular Fountain Sprite®
$2.49
Large Fountain Iced Tea - Unsweet
$2.39
Regular Fountain Iced Tea - Unsweet
$2.49
Large Fountain Iced Tea - Sweet
$2.39
Regular Fountain Iced Tea - Sweet
$2.49
Large Fountain Cherry Coke®
$2.39
Regular Fountain Cherry Coke®
$2.49
Large Fountain Root Beer
$2.39
Regular Fountain Root Beer
$2.49
Large Fountain Powerade® - Mountain Blast
$2.39
Regular Fountain Powerade® - Mountain Blast
$2.49
Large Fountain Hi-C® - Fruit Punch
$2.39
Regular Fountain Hi-C® - Fuit Punch
$2.49
Regular Classic Lemonade
$2.49
Large Classic Lemonade
$2.39
Regular Strawberry Lemonade
$2.49
Large Strawberry Lemonade
$2.39
Reviews
3.6
268 reviews
5 stars
121
4 stars
50
3 stars
28
2 stars
19
1 star
50
- CRCaleb Rusler3 days ago1.0They used to be called freaky fast. They should change it to freaky slow, waited over an hour and a half for my order to be delivered, absolutely ridiculous
- JEJesse Eads5 days ago2.0We frequently purchase lunch for our crew from the Shelbyville Jimmy John’s, but unfortunately, the service has become consistently disappointing. Over the past six months, we’ve regularly waited 40–50 minutes for an order of just three sandwiches. On our most recent visit, we decided to dine in, and it became pretty clear why the wait times have been so long. There appeared to be six employees working, yet only one woman seemed to be moving with any sense of urgency. The overall pace was painfully slow, especially for a restaurant that built its reputation around being “freaky fast.” We’ve been repeat customers and would like to continue ordering here, but waiting nearly an hour for a few sandwiches simply isn’t reasonable. Hopefully management can address the staffing, organization, and sense of urgency at this location.
- AMAlex MeyerAug 7, 20261.0Took 15 minutes to get two sandwiches and they were both made wrong
- KLKim LorenzoJul 26, 20261.0Absolutely the worst customer service around. Not friendly. So very slow. Out of bread often. Never going back. Going to Penn Station across the street. Also filthy
- SMShaun MurnanJun 20, 20262.0Horribly slow every time and the manager on duty was rude. Waited for food only to be told they were out of things. Asked for a refund and the manager acted like it was an inconvenience. Done with this location.
Brand Certified Facts from Jimmy John's
This information is certified by Jimmy John's and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified August 30, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website