Mr Gatti's Pizza

Reviews

• SS

  Snakes be snaking

  Jul 20, 2026
  5.0
  Delicious! Get their apple fruit pie/pizza omg.. you'll thank me. Not a fan of the buffet though. Get the pizza to go and eat it in the vehicle. Lol. I don't understand where the buffet Pizza tastes different but it just tastes way better when you get it to go. When I tried the buffet here I'm just a plain cheese or pepperoni pizza person and the whole time I was there you couldn't request any pizzas because people requested too many or whatever it was so the whole time I was there I had to pick toppings off so I'm not a big fan of doing that in a public place it's kind of gross I don't want my fingers to get all nasty. But with a buffet you would think that there be at least a cheese or pepperoni pizza but the hour and 20 minutes that we were there there we're none. But that's not their fault and that's why I'm just telling you to get it to go. :)
• DW

  Dominique Major Whitaker

  Jul 18, 2026
  1.0
  Everything was awful. The food was gross and the lady at the front was not hospitable.
• TS

  tim spurgeon

  Jul 17, 2026
  1.0
  They are lacking in staff. Ate there and they couldn't keep up with the bar. For most of the time we were there the pizza looked dried up and like it had been there all day.
• MB

  Mary B.

  Jul 16, 2026
  2.0
  I was there in May and the food was great. Yesterday, under new management /ownership, the pizza was not good. The crust looked pre-made, and packaged. Plus, we were there shortly after noon, and there was very little pizza available. And, it didn’t appear to have been very busy. The pizza that WAS there was tough and dried out. I won’t be coming back. Chicago’s has you beaten and it’s on my side of town.
• JT

  jill theis

  Jul 10, 2026
  5.0
  The pizza and buffet is outstanding. We were greeted by the new owners and they were very interested in our opinions. This owner operated business made us feel welcome and will be very popular .

Frequently Asked Questions About Mr Gatti's Pizza