Magoo's California Pizza

Reviews

• EG

  Elias Gilkey

  Jun 30, 2026
  5.0
  Delicious! We got a pepperoni pie, buffalo chicken pie, chappli kebab pie and the jalapeño cheesey garlic bread. All were hot and delicious, and ready on time. Have ordered here before and will do so again!
• LS

  Lily saunders

  Jun 28, 2026
  5.0
  It was my first time there and the pizza was Amazing! The gentleman serving me was incredibly kind and helpful.
• RM

  Raya M

  Jun 27, 2026
  5.0
  I went there after quite a few yrs coz the food was too greasy and spicy. They changed the menu and their steak sandwich was not only a healthy option but also had a mild flavor which goes with American flavor. I hope they keep the standard and cont to serve fresh food. The sitting is just OK but it in Indy area so one can understand the reason.
• AS

  Asif Siddiqui

  Jun 21, 2026
  4.0
  I've visited Magoo's several times, and the food has always been fresh, flavorful, and consistently good. The staff has always been friendly, and it's a place I keep coming back to for the food. That said, the dining area could use some attention. The interior feels quite dated, and many of the tables and chairs appear old and worn. During my most recent visit, the table we were seated at was dirty, and I had to flag down an employee to have it cleaned before we could eat. If you're planning to dine in, I would recommend their other location, which offers a much better dining experience. The food remains excellent, but improvements to the cleanliness and overall condition of the dining area would make this location much more enjoyable.
• CC

  Czargent

  Jun 19, 2026
  5.0
  Possibly one of the best pizzas i’ve had since i've moved to Indiana. The pizza? 10/10. Service? Amazing. Atmosphere? Absolutely stunning; Ranch is beautiful as well. This is legitimately one of (if not) the best pizzas I’ve places i’ve ever bought from. If you’re reading this Alaa, Rachel and Rhonda said hi.