Magoo's California Pizza

Reviews

• KE

  Kylee Egendoerfer

  Aug 14, 2026
  5.0
  Magoo’s is always our go to. Not only is it our preferred pizza in Indy it is always fresh and hot and ready to go. The chicken tikka with garlic sauce never misses! If the food isn’t enough to win you over, the service will. Mohammad greets everyone with the warmest welcome and takes his time with each customer. He remembers everyone and truly makes this location that much better. Always 10/10 recommend!
• HS

  Hameed Salah

  Aug 13, 2026
  5.0
  Magoo's California Pizza is the best Halal pizzeria I know in Indianapolis. No only is their food great but their service is outstanding. Small family owned business that cares about their customers. Once we ordered from Magoo's but the third party delivery service dropped off the food at the wrong location. Magoo's was quick to make us our order again (free of charge!) even though they weren't the ones responsible for the mistake. God bless them! They have earned our business and trust.
• MM

  MoTa

  Aug 9, 2026
  5.0
  We ordered large pizza and it was great! The only downside was that they used pasta sauce instead of traditional pizza sauce, but it was still very good. We called very late, and they were kind enough to take our order and make it fresh even though it was half half. Great food and very accommodating service!
• JM

  Josef McCoy

  Aug 5, 2026
  1.0
  Ordered a cheese pizza and a meatlovers. 7:10 PM. Said it would be delivered 8:10. Fine. Sent a message saying it would instead be 8:15. Fine. 8:45 rolls around. No pizza. I call. They say the delivery guy JUST arrived to pick it up, no phone call nor update to me. I said "hey Im in a hotel room, and I dont want a cold pizza I cant warm up". I got a cold pizza I couldn't warm up, after 9PM. Magoo's is only 12 minutes from where I was staying. So I contacted them back and didn't hear a word back. No one wanted to make it right or even acknowledge the failure. Needless to say, cannot recommend. It's one thing to be a little late. Quite another to take two hours to deliver a pizza 12 minutes away. But the worst thing is the total lack of communication and creativity in solving this, and no accountability after the fact. I can forgive one of the three. I don't even leave reviews often, but I'm leaving this one. This tells me that we're another order to this business. No interest in repeat business. I can get that treatment anywhere.
• SS

  SS.Reviews

  Jul 29, 2026
  5.0
  We had a great experience at Magoo's Pizza! From the moment we walked in, the owner was incredibly welcoming, friendly, and professional. Even though there was a steady rush of customers coming in and out, he made sure we were well taken care of, and the service was truly top-notch. The pizza was excellent—fresh, flavorful, and definitely one of the better halal pizzas we've had. They also serve (zabihah halal meat) which is a huge plus for anyone looking for halal options. You can tell this place is run with care. The owner mentioned he's looking into opening more locations, and after our experience, it's easy to see why. Great food, excellent customer service, and a welcoming atmosphere make this a spot worth supporting. If you're looking for solid pizza with zabihah halal options, definitely give Magoo's Pizza a try. We'll definitely be back!