Magoo's California Pizza

Reviews

• AH

  Angela Harris

  1 day ago
  2.0
  Today I have to give tonight meal a 2 star, im not sure what changed but my medium Supreme pizza was pretty, but it was cold when I got, it was just chewy & dry. My cheese sticks were also chewy not even was warm. Wings were dried out today no flavor. Now I had them before a few times and never had a issue everytime it was great . I have to provide a honest review. I will order again but I was very disappointed because it cost way too much.
• HH

  Hani Haboon

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Amazing experience! The customer service was outstanding—everyone was friendly, welcoming, and made us feel valued from the moment we walked in. The food was absolutely incredible. The pizza is hands down some of the best I’ve ever had. Every bite was fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. Honestly, you’ll never taste pizza as delicious as what they serve here. I highly recommend Magoo’s California Pizza to anyone looking for amazing food and excellent service. I’ll definitely be coming back! 🍕❤️
• SS

  Sydney Smith

  3 days ago
  5.0
  This was my first time ordering and I'm absolutely going to be back! My socks were knocked off not only by the food but by the variety. Absolutely delicious and, as a midwest girlie, that ranch can't be beat. Run, do not walk!
• JD

  Jhene Dorcelien

  Jul 2, 2026
  5.0
  The best pizza I've ever had, no exaggeration. It was so so hot and fresh I had to let out a moan. GET THE CHICKEN TIKKA PIZZA AND THE BBQ PIZZA !!!! Aladdin was extremely friendly and nice to talk to. Def dine in because it might arrive cold if you get it delivered far away from Avon.
• AR

  Adam Rhody

  Jun 25, 2026
  5.0
  This pizza has to be some of the best in the surrounding Indianapolis area. While living in Avon, my wife and I ate here far too often. Now we find ourselves driving back through Avon just for this pizza. On top of the pizza quality, the employees are very kind and welcoming. Don't pass on an opportunity to eat here.