CW
Carla Wilson
Sep 27, 2026
Kountry Kitchen Review — Indianapolis, IN
Since moving to Indianapolis in 2000, I have loved Kountry Kitchen. The food has always been something I could count on, especially the catfish. Unfortunately, since the remodel, my experiences with the service have been disappointing.
The first time I visited after the remodel was a few months ago. My husband and I came for lunch around 11:00 a.m. on a weekday. We stood at the door for at least five minutes before anyone greeted or seated us. There were only two other customers in the restaurant at the time. We asked for a booth and were initially told that booths were generally reserved because they get too busy to seat parties of two there, but they made an exception for us. The restaurant never became busy while we were there.
After being seated, it took at least another 10 minutes for our waitress to take our order, and then about 20 more minutes for our food to arrive. The service was frustratingly slow considering how few customers were there.
That said, the food did not disappoint. My catfish was as good as ever.
Today, my husband and I returned because we had family visiting from out of town. We arrived shortly before 11:00 a.m., and again, the restaurant was nowhere near packed. Our waitress was friendly and did a good job, but once again, it took almost 30 minutes for our food to arrive.
My catfish was perfect—fried just right—and my yams and okra were good as well. Unfortunately, the experience was very different for some of my family members.
My cousin ordered catfish, but hers was barely warm and did not appear to be freshly fried. Her sweet potatoes and macaroni and cheese were dry. My husband ordered eggs, sausage, and home fries. The sausage was overcooked and hard, and the potatoes were white with burnt onions on top.
Another cousin ordered scrambled eggs, but they came folded rather than scrambled and were not completely cooked. She also ordered home fries, which looked the same as my husband's. Her salmon croquettes, however, were good.
The cousin who ordered the catfish didn't even finish her meal because the food simply wasn't up to par.
At that point, we asked to speak with a manager. A woman named Micheon came over. What disappointed me most wasn't just the food or the wait—it was how the situation was handled. There was no apology or acknowledgment of our experience. Instead, the response was essentially, what do you want—should we remake the food?
By then, we had already been there for about an hour and were ready to leave. My cousin asked how long a replacement meal would take, and I asked about getting a refund. I don't want to misquote the manager because I don't remember the conversation word for word, but I will say that her attitude made an already frustrating experience worse.
To her credit, they did replace my cousin's meal, and she received it within about five minutes.
I also want to point out that we weren't the only customers experiencing frustration. There were other patrons around us complaining about the service as well.
I really want to see Kountry Kitchen succeed. I've been eating there since I moved to Indianapolis in 2000, and I genuinely love the food. My catfish was still excellent today, which is why this review isn't about the food being bad across the board. It's about consistency, service, and how customers are treated when something goes wrong.
I hope management takes these concerns seriously because it would be a shame for a restaurant with food I have loved for so many years to lose customers because of the service.
Great food can bring people in, but good service and customer care are what make people want to come back.
HJ
Henry James
Sep 21, 2026
Henry Approves:
What I ordered: Pork chops, green beans, cornbread, and an Arnold Palmer
Total: $30.98
Pork Chops: Needed more seasoning for my taste.
Cornbread Dressing: Dry, I like my dressing moist.
Green Beans: Flavorful and one of the better parts of the meal.
Cornbread: Too dry for my liking. It also came with cold butter sitting on top.
Arnold Palmer: Good.
Service: A little slow, but the servers were friendly and attentive.
Atmosphere: Quiet, clean, and comfortable.
Henry’s Score
Food: 6.5/10
Service: 7.5/10
Atmosphere: 8/10
Value: 7/10
Henry Approves?
I’d give it another shot. The service and atmosphere were solid, but the food needs a little more consistency especially the seasoning on the pork chops and the cornbread.
Overall: 7/10