Turtle Sundae
$6.75
Hot fudge, pecans, and butterscotch over Vanilla Bean ice cream.
Brand Certified
Graeter's Ice Cream
4.6(654 reviews)
Certified by Graeter's Ice Cream • Aug 30, 2026
Business Details
5560 North Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN
46208, United States
Certified by Graeter's Ice Cream • Aug 30, 2026
(317) 253-1405
Certified by Graeter's Ice Cream • Aug 30, 2026
http://www.graeters.com/
Certified by Graeter's Ice Cream • Aug 30, 2026
About
Certified by Graeter's Ice Cream • Aug 30, 2026
Ice Cream ShopGraeter's Ice Cream
Since 1870 Graeter’s has been producing small-batch French Pot ice cream that fans love. We have won the hearts of ice cream lovers across the county and the respect of the nation’s most influential foodies! Give us a try and see what all the fuss is about. We’re sure you’ll fall in love with the legend of Graeter's!
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Requires appointmentNot available
Location
Certified by Graeter's Ice Cream • Aug 30, 2026
Hours
Certified by Graeter's Ice Cream • Aug 30, 2026
Monday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Saturday11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Sunday12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Menu
1 menu · 34 items
Explore offerings from Graeter's Ice Cream on 5560 North Illinois St in Indianapolis, with popular menu available at this location.
Menu
34 items
Menu
Cookie Monster
$7.75
Cookie Dough and Cookies & Cream ice creams, hot fudge and chocolate sprinkles
Includes one topping, whipped cream and a cherry with two scoops
Includes one topping, whipped cream and a cherry
Double Scoop Waffle Cone
$7.25
Cones/Dishes
Frozen Drinks
Frozen Drinks
$7.00
Frozen Drinks
Pints
$6.99
Freezer Cling
Double Scoop Dish
$6.25
Cones/Dishes
Single Scoop Waffle Cone
$5.75
Cones/Dishes
Traditional Dish
$5.25
Cones/Dishes
Big Scoops
$4.75
4.5oz cups ice cream available in these flavors: Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Chocolate Chip Double Chocolate Chip Mint Chocolate Chip Madagascar Vanilla Bean
Ice Cream Cakes
$34.95
We take one of our freshly baked yellow or chocolate 8" round cakes and slice it through the middle. In between, we place over one pound of irresistible Graeter's ice cream. We finish it off with a layer of homemade topping and surround the sides with a gourmet blend frosting.
Ice Cream Pies
$34.95
Our pies are made with a 9-inch chocolate graham cookie crust filled with nearly two pounds of our ice cream, capped with one of our homemade toppings and trimmed with a gourmet blend frosting. All cakes and pies will comfortably serve 10-12 people.
56 oz
$19.99
56 oz. ice cream
Chip Wheelies
$4.75
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Kid's Sundae
$5.75
Major League Sundae
$6.75
Featured
1870 Tower
$7.25
Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip ice cream, chocolate bundt cake, hot fudge, fresh whipped cream, pecans and a cherry
Brownie Sundae
$7.25
Featured
Banana Split
$8.00
Featured
Large Double Dip Soda 24 oz
$6.50
Frozen Drinks
Medium Double Dip Soda 20oz
$6.00
Frozen Drinks
Large Milkshake 24oz
$7.50
Frozen Drinks
Small Milkshake 16oz
$6.50
Frozen Drinks
Specialty Sundae
$6.75
Sundaes
Single Scoop Sugar Cone
$4.75
Cones/Dishes
Double Scoop Sugar Cone
$6.25
Cones/Dishes
Double Scoop Sprinkle Deluxe
$8.00
Cones/Dishes
Single Scoop Sprinkle Deluxe
$6.50
Cones/Dishes
Double Scoop Chocolate Dip
$7.75
Cones/Dishes
Double Scoop Choc Dipped Waffle Cone
$7.75
Cones/Dishes
Single Scoop Specialty Choc Dip
$6.25
Cones/Dishes
Extra Scoop
$1.50
Cones/Dishes
Reviews
4.6
654 reviews
5 stars
495
4 stars
70
3 stars
24
2 stars
13
1 star
14
- MMMichael Merriman5 days ago1.0Really not that great to be honest. We hadn't ever had Graeter's, but heard it was good. We were sorry to be disappointed. Ice cream was bland with a chemical taste to it. The brownie was hard. Just feels like another franchise ice cream shop. Employees did their job. Seemed kind of annoyed by us being there, but they did everything we needed.
- JCJoe CollierAug 16, 20262.0Website says they close at 11pm I brought my son at 10:11pm and the doors were locked with the employees there…very annoying
- JMJosh “Flametouched” McCleereyAug 15, 20265.0Great ice cream friendly atmosphere.
- JNJacob NobbeAug 2, 20265.0Great spot in a cozy neighborhood location! Service is usually okay. The ice cream is always consistently the best around!
- MHMike hallJul 30, 20265.0Hands down, best ice cream around.
Frequently Asked Questions About Graeter's Ice Cream
What makes Graeter's Ice Cream special?
Graeter's has been producing small-batch French Pot ice cream since 1870, winning the hearts of ice cream lovers nationwide with its unique flavors and quality.
Where is Graeter's Ice Cream located?
Graeter's Ice Cream is located at 5560 North Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46208, in the Butler-Tarkington neighborhood.
What are the operating hours of Graeter's Ice Cream?
Graeter's is open Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 10:00 PM.
What payment options are accepted at Graeter's Ice Cream?
They accept Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Does Graeter's offer delivery or takeout services?
Yes, Graeter's offers both takeout and same-day delivery services.
Can I find Graeter's Ice Cream on social media or download their app?
Yes, Graeter's is available on Facebook at GraetersIllinoisStreet, Instagram @graeters, Twitter @graeters, and they have Android and iOS apps.
Are there nearby places to visit when coming to Graeter's Ice Cream?
Yes, you can visit nearby spots like Illinois Street Food Emporium for deli and bakery items, CVS Pharmacy for your medical needs, or enjoy coffee at Tinker Coffee - The Firehouse or Starbucks before or after your ice cream visit.
Where can I find ATMs near Graeter's Ice Cream?
Nearby ATMs include The Exchange Network, LibertyX Bitcoin ATM, Bitcoin Depot, and RockItCoin Bitcoin ATM for your convenience.
What other food options are close to Graeter's Ice Cream?
You can explore eateries nearby such as Oh Yumm Bistro, Byrne's Grilled Pizza, Essenhaus Restaurant and Bakery, and The Flying Cupcake for a variety of delicious meals.
Does Graeter's Ice Cream offer catering or special products?
Yes, Graeter's provides catering services and specializes in Ice Cream, Candy, Ice Cream Cakes, Chip Wheelies, and Ice Cream Pints.
Brand Certified Facts from Graeter's Ice Cream
This information is certified by Graeter's Ice Cream and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified August 30, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: