Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• KA

  Kaia Mei Atkinson

  Apr 19, 2026
  3.0
  More often than not my orders from here are wrong. The last time I went the employees were very adamant about carrying my pizza to my car. It felt like I was begging them not help me. I was by myself and I know they were trying to be nice but I really don't want 2 men I don't know to follow me to my car. Eventually they gave me the pizzas but I definitely had to ask more than once. They also are in the worst parking lot in all of Ellettsville. The lot has the worst set up ever.
• KG

  Kristina Galloway

  Apr 7, 2026
  5.0
  We love Papa John's
• AM

  Addison Martin

  Jan 11, 2026
  4.0
  and it was free over a mistake they made js call and ask and they’ll get it done
• KS

  kim sollers

  Jan 4, 2026
  2.0
  Ordered ahead, said order was ready however after arriving for pick up had to wait another 10 mins because employee was on the phone and another employee didn't offer to address me, like I wasn't even there. Didn't yell back to get their attention as front employee was on the phone. Person on phone could of acknowledged me and even the other employee who did come up front while I was standing there, could of acknowledged me as well, but didn't.
• SB

  steven burke

  Jan 1, 2026
  1.0
  I called and ordered an anchovies pizza for pickup omw to work, i asked and double checked and they said they did have anchovies. I got their on time and heard them say to call customer we dont have anchovies so I walked out, they hadn't even put my pizza in the oven yet. They called me and said we'll if you were their why didnt you say something you wasted our time calling you. Now I'm at work hungry all night after they wasted MY time when I could have gone somewhere else that wasn't on some bs and had my food on time.