Mr Gatti's Pizza

Reviews

• JM

  Just ME!

  4 days ago
  3.0
  It was Extremely hot in there and I think they had 2 pizzas ready 1 cheese and 1 pepperoni. So It's not a place I would choose again. Apparently. Alot of people feel the same cause they only had 1 other customer while we ate there. Maybe that explains why only 2 pizza's.
• CW

  Casey Whitmire

  Jul 18, 2026
  1.0
  The worst Gattis I’ve ever had. Place was a ghost town at 5:30 on a Saturday for good reason. Ordered two fresh pizzas to go and they were burnt to a crisp and inedible. Would have taken them back but we were driving cross country and didn’t seem worth the hassle to give them another chance. This location should be closed.
• LM

  Lonnie Mallard

  Jul 18, 2026
  2.0
  Pizza tasted funny like freezer burned do
• AT

  Autumn Turner

  Jul 12, 2026
  5.0
  I’ve love coming here ever since I was a kid and prefer it to the Louisville locations because it stayed the same as when I was a kid. Good food with great staff. There was a sign out front warning about no ice which was really disappointing, but Richard ran out to let us know they did have ice, it was just low. When we first walked in and paid, we were immediately asked if we wanted to request anything which was great. We sat down and Richard came over to give us his name and let us know he did the dishes. He was awesome to chat and joke around with. We requested a chicken bacon ranch pizza (was going to request a bbq chicken but one was already out) and then a s’mores pizza. If you haven’t had the s’mores pizza and you like chocolate, you need to try it because it’s amazing. Let’s be real, it’s a pizza buffet. Don’t expect paying the same as ordering a single pizza for 2+ people and get the same quality. We spent $26 after tax for 2 people during lunch time. Realistically, that’s the same price as fast food joints now. The pizza is good. Yes, the crust is typically harder but most people don’t eat the crust anyway. The food is good, service phenomenal, and it’s just a fun nostalgic place. If you haven’t been here, I recommend trying it at least once. Especially if you have little ones that like pizza.
• CW

  Col. Jim Worrall

  Jul 10, 2026
  2.0
  Salad bar was not fresh and very limited. Extremely expensive for pizza and iceberg lettuce. For the same price you can eat at a buffet with steak down the street or Asian buffets with over 100 choices. Filthy restrooms.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mr Gatti's Pizza