South Shore Pizzeria

Reviews

• JM

  Johnny Maz

  Jun 15, 2026
  5.0
  Wish we would have ordered some food but went in for a quick cocktail. Our drinks were great and we had very friendly service. Next time we are in town we will definitely try a pie and some other menu items!
• MH

  Makayla Hoch

  May 30, 2026
  2.0
  I’ve tried to overlook this place’s customer service for a long time, but today was the last straw. Every time I order online or through DoorDash and come in for pickup, I tell them my name and that I have an order ready. Every single time, they look confused, say they don’t know if it’s done, and then disappear into the back for a long time. I’ve always let that slide. But today was different. The woman who handed me my food was completely rude. She walked up looking irritated, asked if I had a DoorDash order in a nasty tone, and when I paused trying to remember whether I ordered online or through DoorDash, she got even more rude. Then she asked, “Do you even know what you ordered?” in the same attitude-filled voice. When I told her, she rolled her eyes and gave me a dirty look. If you work in food service, basic kindness and professionalism should not be optional. A smile and a respectful tone go a long way. I will not be returning or ordering from here again. The service needs to change.
• JG

  Jenny G.

  May 17, 2026
  5.0
  Don't let the name change fool you! This is the same amazing pizza and vibe you've always loved. We had the appetizer platter and pizza. The leftovers will last multiple days. We've been here so many times and will keep coming back because the food and service are always on point. ❤️
• LH

  Laura Henley

  May 17, 2026
  5.0
  Excellent dinner. The waitresses was very friendly and the service was fast. Good eats. I'll be back. Stop in here for great food at good prices. I'll ne a regular.
• MD

  Martin Duffy

  Apr 11, 2026
  5.0
  Wasn't busy. Love the cracker crust pizza. Just like the one in New Buffalo but smaller.