Jimmy John's

Reviews

• LW

  Larry Wiznowski

  Aug 25, 2026
  1.0
  Nine out of 10 times there’s always something wrong, it’s always a missing sandwich or they don’t hardly put any ingredients on the sandwich, or they just don’t know what they are doing. Tonight was one of those times they messed up again. Ordered homestyle potato salad looked at the best by date says it’s good only until Yesterday end of day, which would be the 24th, today is the 25th and I got it end of day. I don’t understand how mess ups constantly keep happening. I keep going back because I want to give them a fair shot. But this is too much, reading the date is too hard? Is it that hard to find decent help in Marengo?
• JJ

  Janet

  Jul 15, 2026
  3.0
  Very nice employees. One complaint...their bread wasn't the same as what I have had at other locations. It was tasteless, as if something was missing.
• SS

  Scott Schirmer

  Jun 19, 2026
  1.0
  The worst Jimmy John's ever. Hopefully you dont want your sandwiches in less than an hour because you're going to be waiting at least that long. *toasted sandwiches not toasted * was basically told if I wasnt happy to not order there anymore
• JW

  Jeni Warden

  Jun 3, 2026
  5.0
  Just popped in for the first time to split a quick lunch before running errands, and had a great experience. The team working this morning was friendly and smiling. It definitely makes a difference. My sandwich was made with good vibes!
• JN

  justagirL noyb

  May 31, 2026
  1.0
  I wanted to order 4 sandwiches. I asked to have my sandwich toasted and was denied because it wasn't a "toasted" sandwich. I said I was confused because Huntley location has no issue toasting my sandwich regardless of type of sandwich. He said the turkey tom doesn't have the toaster fee included in the price. Sometimes you have to ask yourself is this real life? So I asked him if he was kidding? He said this isn't a joke. The problem solver I am I asked if I could pay a toaster fee? He said no its the owners rules here I can not help you. So I gave my business to Huntley since we were heading that way. I will not be back I have zero patience for playing games it shouldn't be this complicated or hard to spend my hard earned money!